LIST006a (C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03
|
In the following verses the keyword IT means ONLY IT
This emphasis can eg mean that
- the law ONLY APPLIES to this offering but not to
similar offerings or
- the laws mentioned in the chapter are essential
That is ALL the procedures must be done and then
ONLY IT (when all the procedures are done) enable
the sacrifice to achieve its status.
- All procedures in the chapter must be perceived
as parts that contribute to an entire process
(eg A sin offering must have done to it all
procedures in the sin offering chapter and these
procedures must be perceived as making the sin
offering- if they are done in isolation we dont
have a sin offering)
We hope to eventually have all IT Rashis in this list
|
VERSE
|
Text of verse with ONLY IT
|
ONLY IT excludes
|
Lv07-01a
|
ONLY It is a guilt offering
|
An exchanged animal*1
|
Lv07-06a
|
ONLY IT is holy holies
|
Nazarite offering *2
|
--------
|
----------------------------
|
---------------------
|
Lv02-06b
|
ONLY IT is a Minchah
|
Procedurs essential*3
|
Lv04-24b
|
ONLY it is a SIN OFFERING
|
Procedurs essential*4
|
Lv05-09b
|
ONLY it is a sin offering
|
Procedurs essential*4
|
Lv05-12b
|
ONLY it is a sin offering
|
Procedurs essential*4
|
Lv06-02c
|
ONLY it is an UP offering
|
Procedurs essential*5
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
COMMENTS
|
*1 So if a guilt offering animal got mixed up in a pen
with other animals that eg were designated as
thanksgiving offerings then you dont have the right
to offer SOME animal as a guilt offering--specificity
of animal is a requirement
*2 The verse says that the GUILT OFFERING is eaten by
males because ONLY IT is holy of holies. This ONLY
IT excludes SIMILAR OFFERINGS (like the Nazarite
Ram which resembles the GUILT offering in allowed
TIME of consumption but nevertheless does not
have a HOLY OF HOLY status)
*3 All procedures mentioned in the paragraph are essential
For example POURING OIL is essential to the Minchah
*4 All procedures mentioned in the paragraph are essential
All procedures in the chapter must be perceived
as parts that contribute to an entire process
(eg A sin offering must have done to it all
procedures in the sin offering chapter and these
procedures must be perceived as making the sin
offering- if they are done in isolation we dont
have a sin offering)
*5 ONLY IT IS AN UP OFFERING teaches us that only valid
UP offerings may have their organs lie on the altar.
(An invalid UP offering may not have its organs lie
on the altar)
|