Gn01-11d (C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03
|
Posting #1 in a series of 7
SUCCINCT SUMMARY
----------------
Many Rashis focus on an ALIGNMENT of almost similar verses
By examining the minor differences in these verses we can
infer many new nuances.
Traditionally some Rashi-ists such as Dr Leibowitz or Rabbi
Boncheck see Rashi as explaining extra words. In this email
list we do not use the EXTRA WORD rule--instead we use
a similar rule---EXTRA WORDS WHOSE EXTRA-NESS IS SEEN IN
ALIGNMENTS indicates intentional nuances in the text. Thus
we only seek to explain those EXTRA WORDS if they occur in
aligned texts.
EXAMPLE 1
---------
- Gn01-11 Grass that SEEDS SEED
- Gn01-12 Trees with SEEDS IN THEM
RASHI: Grass seeds scattered by wind while tree seeds are sown
EXAMPLE 2
---------
- Gn01-03 Let there be LIGHT
- Gn01-14 Let there be SUN/STARS
RASHI: RAW Light created on day 1; SOURCES of light created
on subsequent days in creation
EXAMPLE 3
---------
- Gn01-11 Let there be GRASS, TREES BY SPECIES
- Gn01-12 There came forth GRASS BY SPECIES and TREES BY SPECIES
RASHI: The BY SPECIES laws (No incest, bestiality, adultery
etc) is very important and must be complied with even when
not explicitly stated (Hence the grass observed it without
being commanded)
EXAMPLE 4
---------
-Gn01-01 DEITY created world
-Gn02-04 DEITY GOD created world
RASHI: To create world we need both
-- the established order (DEITY)
-- new life (GOD)
EXAMPLE 5
---------
-Gn01-11 Let there be TREES OF FRUIT
-Gn01-12 there came forth TREES BEARING FRUIT
RASHI: Original intention was that FRUIT and TREE should
resemble each other (Eg taste the same) But the TREES
disobeyed and made fruit (whose taste) didnt resemble trees
EXAMPLE 6
---------
-Gn01-01 God created ALL OF (Aleph Tauv) Heaven/Earth
-Gn02-04 God created ------------------- Heaven/Earth
RASHI: ALL OF creation created on Day 1; details were
then fixed and developed on subsequent days
|
ITEM
|
DETAIL
|
RASHI RULE CLASS:
|
ALIGNMENT
|
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS
|
2 CASES
|
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE
|
#10
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST313d
|
Alignment of plant types
|
Producing Seeds(seeds-in/out of plant)
|
------------------------
|
--------------------------------------
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST313e
|
Align of Gn01-03 Gn01-14
|
Creation of LIGHT vs SUN
|
------------------------
|
--------------------------------------
|
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS
|
NUANCES
|
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE
|
#11
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST307r
|
Align Gn01-11 Gn01-12
|
BY SPECIES mentioned by TREE,not GRASS
|
------------------------
|
--------------------------------------
|
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS
|
NUANCES
|
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE
|
#11
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST307s
|
Align Gn01-01 Gn02-04
|
World created by GOD vs DEITY
|
------------------------
|
--------------------------------------
|
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS
|
NUANCES
|
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE
|
#11
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST307t
|
Align Gn01-11 Gn01-12
|
TREES making fruit vs TREES of fruit
|
------------------------
|
--------------------------------------
|
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS
|
MEANING
|
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE
|
#12
|
SEE BELOW
|
LIST343b
|
Align of Gn01-01 Gn02-04
|
Creation of HEAVEN vs ALL OF HEAVEN
|