(c) 2000 Dr Hendel; 1st appeared in Bais Medrash (c) Torah.Org
Date: Sun, 10 Jan 1999 20:53:29 -0500 (EST)
From: Russell Hendel < email@example.com>
Subject: Re: Joseph recognized his brothers
Alot of discussion has been generated about the repeated verse < ..and
Joseph recognized his brothers...> (Gen 42:7 and Gen 42:8) (question posted
by Michael Turniansky < firstname.lastname@example.org> in V1 #66).
I believe ALL discussions start with the premise that the Torah NEVER
wastes a word. (The explanations then use this principle to e.g. say that
one perception was physical and one was emotional etc)
Actually this "never wastes a word" principle requires clarification.
It turns out that there are at least two rashis (Ex 1:1 and explicitly in
Gen 46:2) that suggest that repeated name calling or mention of
relationships denotes a STYLE indicating affection. It is not necessary to
take each repeated word as indicating some additional attribute.
Let me be crystal clear about this Rashi: According to Rashi it would be
incorrect to look at Gen 46:2 "...and God said Jacob Jacob" and e.g. say
that > > the 1st Jacob was to address his physical self while the 2nd his
spiritual self< < . On the contrary, the simple interpretation is that the
repeated calling simply denotes AFFECTION. Rashi makes an identical point
on the repeated enumeration of the genealogies of the Jews.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: The above approach to Rashi on Ex 1:1 and Gen 46:2 was
presented in a new email group RASHI-IS-SIMPLE which intends to give the
logical derivation of all 8000 rashis on chumash. If you would like to
subscribe mail the moderator (me) or better still email
LISTPROC@SHAMASH.ORG with a message in the body of the email at the
beginning of a line "subscribe rashi-is-simple EMAILADDRESS FIRSTNAME
Russell Jay Hendel; Phd ASA
RHendel @ mcs drexel edu