Verse
Dt16-11a
discussing
the enjoyment of the festivals
states
#####
Rashi notes
that
the underlined words,
and the Levite who is inside your gates, and the non-citizen, and the orphan, and the widow, who are among you
references
verses
Dt14-28:29
discussing
the enjoyment on festivals which requires remembering the poor.
Hence the Rashi comment
The statement that besides rejoicing with your family you must rejoice with
the Levite, non-citizens, orphans and widows references verse Dt14-29
which explicitly states that in order to merit God's blessings you must share with
these underprivileged groups.
Text of Target Verse Dt16-11a
|
Text of Reference Verse Dt14-28:29
|
#####
|
At the end of three years you shall bring forth all the tithe of your produce in that year, and shall lay it up inside your gates;
#####
|
Rashi comments:
The statement that besides rejoicing with your family you must rejoice with
the Levite, non-citizen, orphan and widow references verse Dt14-29
which explicitly states that in order to merit God's blessings you must share with
these underprivileged groups.
|
Advanced Rashi: Rashi literally says There are four household members mentioned: 1) your son, 2) your
daughter, 3) your male servants and 4) your female servants. I, God added four members who are so to
speak my household members: 1) The Levite
2) The non citizen, 3) the widow and 4) orphan. If you help my household members I will help your household members.
It appears that Rashi is aligning the four and four. However there is no Rashi rule which would justify this.
Furthermore, you cannot make inferences based on such numerical alignments. Therefore I sought a standard Rashi rule
that would justify Rashi's inference. I found that the idea that gladdening these 4 categories will earn you God's merit
explicitly referenced in Dt14-29. It immediately follows that this Rashi is using the reference rule. Rashi's language is a formulation of his comment
as a clever pun on numerical coincidence to help people remember the comment - however the real driving force of the Rashi comment
is the reference rule.
The serious student of Rashi is encouraged to review the above example until they fully understand it since this
example shows how to differentiate between the true reason for Rashi vs. the form in which he states his comments.
This study will lead to a more meaningful acceptance of Rashi comments since they are accepted based on rules that
may be repeatedly used!
|