Verses Lv09-01:02 describing the
Priestly inauguration offering
states
And he said to Aaron,
Take a one year old calf for a sin offering, and a ram for a burnt offering, without blemish, and offer them before the Lord.
Rashi Lv09-07d explains that
As the underlined words indicate the word calf
generally means an ox of age 1 (strictly under 2).
Advanced Rashi: The astute reader will recognize
this Rashi as one of the famous hermeunetical rules of Rabbi Ishmael:
If some class [e.g. the class of calfs]
has an anomaly [e.g. one verse speaks about one-year calfs]
then that anomaly [e.g. the fact that calfs must be one year
old] applies to the whole class [e.g. all calfs must be
one year] and not only to that case [e.g. in other words
it is not just the priest-inaugral calf that must be one year
but all calfs generally must be one year].
I have in my Rashi classes explained this Rabbi Ishmael
principle more thoroughly as follows:
- We all know the heuristic that calfs are young oxen
- However we don't know how young
- So if the above two criteria are met
- We have a general idea
- but we don't have details
then we may generalize a specific verse to all cases
assuming there are no verses contradicting our
generalization.
Note the Davka translation renders the above verse
young calf thereby avoiding the literal Biblical text
which states one year old calf. We see here the superiority
of the Hebrew text as understood by Rashi over even a good
English translations.
|