We have explained in our article
Biblical Formatting located on the world wide web at
http://www.Rashiyomi.com/biblicalformatting.pdf,
that the Biblical Author indicates bold, italics, underline by using
repetition. In other words if a modern author wanted to emphasize
a word they would either underline, bold or italicize it. However when the Biblical
author wishes to emphasize a word He repeats it. The effect - whether
thru repetition or using underline - is the same. It is only the
means of conveying this emphasis that is different.
With this in mind let us read verse
Lv21-05,
which discusses the prohibition of making
cuts in ones flesh, an ancient idolatrous practice.
They shall not make baldness upon their head,
neither shall they shave off the corners of their beard,
nor cut any cuttings in their flesh.
The emphasis cut...cutting motivates the
Rashi comment:
The usual implementation of this idolatrous
practice is to cut up one's hands or legs.
I might therefore think that one cut is permissable
(or at least not Biblically prohibited). Therefore
the Bible emphasizes do not cut a cut, even
one.
Further illumination is provided in the advanced
Rashi section.
Advanced Rashi:
Rashi actually cites two rules- the format
rule and the alignment rule. Rashi aligns
- Lv23-05
nor cut any cuttings in their flesh.
- with Lv19-28
nor place any soul-cuts upon you: I am HaShem.
Note the aligned contrast between
cutting cuts vs. placing cuts. Hence
the Rashi comment:
There is a prohibition of placing a set
of cuts on you (which is the usual way this idolatrous
practice is used) as well as cutting individual
cuts. Furthermore if you placed a set of 40 cuts
on your arm (slashed your arm)you have not violated
one prohibition - don't place a cut -
but rather violated 40 prohibitions - don't cut
a cut.
If one carefully examines the structure of this Rashi,
Rashi is noting two stylistic indicators, each one with its
own exegetical inference:
- From the repetition, don't cut
any cuts Rashi infers that even making
one cut is prohibited
- From the alignment, don't place|cut
cuts Rashi infers that when you place a group of several
dozen cuts on yourself you have not violated one prohibition but
rather have violated a group of violations (one violation
per cut).
I believe the above is exemplary of how superficially
excessive exegesis can be understood compactly and simply
as emanating from diverse principles.
One final point: Note, in the aligned verses
above, the aligned
words flesh / soul. Rashi does not comment
on this aligned difference though obviously
it is important. In general after performing an
alignment one should not be disappointed if
one understands only some of the aligned items
from the Rashis on the verse. Other exegesis may however
be present in the Talmud, Sifra or other Midrashic books.
|