Rashi-Is-Simple Mailing List VISIT the RASHI DATABASE archives AT http://www.RashiYomi.com/ Surfing the Talmudic Seas (C) RashiYomi Incorporated, 2003 Written by Dr Russell Jay Hendel Volume 17 Number 6 For the WORD QUALITY HTML VERSION click here ----------------------------------- http://www.Rashiyomi.com/h17n6.htm ----------------------------------- Produced March 5th, 2003 WARNING: USE FIXED WIDTH FONTS (eg COURIER (NEW) 10) |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | ||
Whats new and hot in this issue? | ||
ITEM | WHATS NEW & HOT IN THIS ISSUE |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | |||
| |||
VERSE | RULE | BRIEF DESCRIPTION | |
======== | =============== | ===================================== | |
Lv07-02a | GRAMMARr | PLURAL & SINGULAR in one sentence | |
Lv01-02h | GRAMMARr | PLURAL & SINGULAR in one sentence | |
Lv01-02i | GRAMMARr | PLURAL & SINGULAR in one sentence | |
Gn49-28c | GRAMMARr | PLURAL & SINGULAR in one sentence | |
Lv07-01a | GRAMMARr | IT means ONLY IT | |
Lv07-06a | GRAMMARr | IT means ONLY IT | |
--------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------- |
#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc.2003, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#*#
VERSE: Lv07-02a
RASHIS COVERD: Lv07-02a Lv01-02h Lv01-02i Gn49-28c
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | ||
VERY BRIEF SUMMARY ------------------ One of Rashis 6 main goals is to explain the rules of Grammar the same way Hebrew grammar books explain grammar. One important focus of grammar is the plural-singular principles. Many people naively believe that every sentence must be ALL singular or ALL plural. In fact combining SINGULAR with PLURAL is very common in sentences. A variety of examples and rules are presented below. Here are some simple guidelines and examples RULE 1 ------ SINGULR(V) SINGULAR(S)--eg EACH PERSON HE MOUNTS -- SINGULAR SINGULAR is used to indicate NO commonality (Every person does it his own way) EXAMPLE ------- After Benjamin was caught, each of Jacobs sons, HE MOUNTED HIS DONKEY (RASHI: They were so upset they mounted individually without helping each other) RULE 2 ------ PLURAL(V) SINGULAR(S) SINGULAR(DO)-eg -- each person THEY RETURN to HIS inheritance PLURAL SINGULAR SINGULAR indicates ---- a COMMON act ---- but INDIVIDUALLY done EXAMPLE ------- So the JUBILEE year is a COMMON free-er of all slaves (PLURAL: THEY RETURN). But each person goes back to HIS individual inheritance. RULE 3 ------ PLURAL(V) PLURAL (S)--eg THEY offer THEIR sacrifices PLURAL PLURAL indicates a COMMUNAL act done by the community as a whole. EXAMPLE -------- So SINGULAR (HE OFFERS) indicates a personal UP offering while by contrast a PLURAL (THEY OFFER) indicates a COMMUNITY UP OFFERING (Brought by the community as a whole) There are more rules but this will suffice for now | ||
ITEM | DETAIL | |
RASHI RULE CLASS: | GRAMMARr | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS: | PLURAL-SINGULAR | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #9 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST070a | |
List of verses with | Plural-Singular verses |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | ||||
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: This whole list and set ---------------- of principles is due to MALBIM whose teachings on the simplicity of Biblical exegesis are profound and everlasting. OUr modest contribution is to present HIS list in tabular FORMAT. The list below presents verses which mix SINGULAR and PLURAL. Here are some rough rules RULE 1 ------ SINGULR(V) SINGULAR(S)--eg EACH PERSON HE MOUNTS SINGULAR SINGULAR is used to indicate NO commonality (Every person does it his own way) RULE 2 ------ PLURAL(V) SINGULAR(S) SINGULAR(DO)-eg -- each person RETURNS to HIS inheritance PLURAL SINGULAR SINGULAR indicates ---- a COMMON act ---- but INDIVIDUALLY done RULE 3 ------ PLURAL(V) PLURAL (S)--eg THEY offer THEIR sacrifices PLURAL PLURAL indicates a COMMUNAL act done by the community as a whole. There are more rules but this will suffice for now | ||||
SINGULAR S | PLURAL Verb | SINGULAR OBJECT | VERSE | |
Each person | unloaded*1 | his sack | Gn44-11 | |
Each person | dreamed*1 | his dream | Gn40-05 | |
Each person | sold *1 | his field | Gn47-20 | |
Each person | gleaned*1 | his needs | Gn16-16 | |
Each person | opened *1 | his sack | Gn44-11 | |
Each person | returns*1 | to his inheritance | Lv25-13 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
each person | won-t withold | his burial plot*2 | Gn23-06 | |
Each person | if he suspects | his wife *2 | Nu05-12 | |
Each person | if he redeems | his tenth *2 | Lv27-31 | |
let them | make tzitzith | for themselves*3 | Nu15-38 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
each person | was blessed | by his blessing *4 | Gn49-28c | |
each person | took | his sword *4 | Gn34-25 | |
each person | took | his incensor*4 | Lv10-01 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
each person | HE mounted | his donkey *5 | Gn44-13 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
each person | who offers | a sacrifice | Lv01-02 | |
they will | offer | their sacrifices*6 | Lv01-02 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
where they | they slaughter | the UP Offering | Lv07-01 | |
(there..) | they slaughter | the GUILT offering | Lv07-01 | |
its blood | he spills*7 | on the altar | Lv07-01 | |
----------- | -------------- | ------------------ | ------- | |
|
||||
*1 This PLURAL-SINGULAR is rather normal usage. So eg EACH PERSON THEY UNLOADED THEIR SACKS means that - they unloaded TOGETHER (eg at the same time or helping each other) - but they each unloaded their individual sacks *2 Note the IF and NOT. The SINGULAR SINGULAR is appropriate. Eg IF SOMEONE SUSPECTS HIS WIFE (It doesnt necessarily apply to the whole group)! Similarly NO INDIVIDUAL PERSON WILL DENY HIS BURIAL PLOT TO YOU means that no particular person will so deny. *3 Malbim suggests that COMMANDS can be stated in the plural when they apply to everybody (that is everybody has to make Tzitzith) *4 So we see elements of COMMONALITY (PLURAL) and INDIVIDUALITY (SINGULAR) in these verses. - Each person THEY took HIS incensor RASHI: They didnt do it as a group The didnt consult each other - Each person THEY took HIS sword RASHI: They didnt do it as group They didnt consult each other - Each person THEY WERE BLESSED according to THEIR blessing RASHI: So although the blessings were individual (eg Judah was a lion and Naftali was a Gazelle) nevertheless their was a commonality--that is Jacob bless all of them as a group with the blessings and benefits of each individual member. *5 Note the SINGULAR SINGULAR form---the brothers were upset at Benjamin being framed and hence they didnt think of each other---they EACH MOUNTED IN THEIR OWN WAY WITHOUT ANY UNISON *6 So the first part of the verse talks about offering a voluntary individual offering. The 2nd part of the verse speaks about offering a voluntary communal offering (Hence the singular-plural) *7 So although the verse talks about the GUILT offering nevertheless, it makes a general comment about COMMUNAL offerings: - wherever ANY communal UP offering is slaughtered - there, the GUILT offering is slaughtered As a side inference we see that the Torah assumes that ALL UP offerings (Individual-communal) are offered in the NORTH |
#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc.2003, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#
VERSE: Lv07-01a
RASHIS COVERED: Lv07-01a Lv07-06a
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | ||
VERY BRIEF SUMMARY ------------------ One of Rashis 6 main goals is to explain grammar the same way Hebrew grammar books explain grammar. One function of grammar is to provide special words which create nuances of emphasis. Words like ALSO, ONLY, BUT, EXCEPT etc. One such word is IT. A typical Hebrew sentence would read IT WILL BE HOLY TO YOU (Nu18-09). However several verses use the alternative construct IT IS HOLY. Although this construction IT occurs in several verses the Talmud universally interprets IT as ONLY IT. The list below gives several examples. We hope eventually to gather all examples in one place EXAMPLE ------- IT IS A GUILT OFFERING (RASHI: But if it got exchanged with another animal then that exchanged animal does not acquire the GUILT OFFERING STATUS) Hence RASHI interprets IT as meaning ONLY IT EXAMPLE ------- ONLY MALES CAN EAT IT...IT IS HOLY RASHI: ONLY IT is holy but the comparable offerings of the NAZARITE RAM or the THANKSGIVING OFFERING do not have HOLY status. | ||
ITEM | DETAIL | |
RASHI RULE CLASS: | GRAMMARr | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS: | SPECIAL WORDS | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #9 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST006a | |
List of verses with | Plural-Singular verses |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-03 | |||
In the following verses the keyword IT means ONLY IT This emphasis can eg mean that - the law ONLY APPLIES to this offering but not to similar offerings or - the laws mentioned in the chapter are essential That is ALL the procedures must be done and then ONLY IT (when all the procedures are done) enable the sacrifice to achieve its status. - All procedures in the chapter must be perceived as parts that contribute to an entire process (eg A sin offering must have done to it all procedures in the sin offering chapter and these procedures must be perceived as making the sin offering- if they are done in isolation we dont have a sin offering) We hope to eventually have all IT Rashis in this list | |||
VERSE | Text of verse with ONLY IT | ONLY IT excludes | |
Lv07-01a | ONLY It is a guilt offering | An exchanged animal*1 | |
Lv07-06a | ONLY IT is holy holies | Nazarite offering *2 | |
-------- | ---------------------------- | --------------------- | |
Lv02-06b | ONLY IT is a Minchah | Procedurs essential*3 | |
Lv04-24b | ONLY it is a SIN OFFERING | Procedurs essential*4 | |
Lv05-09b | ONLY it is a sin offering | Procedurs essential*4 | |
Lv05-12b | ONLY it is a sin offering | Procedurs essential*4 | |
Lv06-02c | ONLY it is an UP offering | Procedurs essential*5 | |
|
|||
*1 So if a guilt offering animal got mixed up in a pen with other animals that eg were designated as thanksgiving offerings then you dont have the right to offer SOME animal as a guilt offering--specificity of animal is a requirement *2 The verse says that the GUILT OFFERING is eaten by males because ONLY IT is holy of holies. This ONLY IT excludes SIMILAR OFFERINGS (like the Nazarite Ram which resembles the GUILT offering in allowed TIME of consumption but nevertheless does not have a HOLY OF HOLY status) *3 All procedures mentioned in the paragraph are essential For example POURING OIL is essential to the Minchah *4 All procedures mentioned in the paragraph are essential All procedures in the chapter must be perceived as parts that contribute to an entire process (eg A sin offering must have done to it all procedures in the sin offering chapter and these procedures must be perceived as making the sin offering- if they are done in isolation we dont have a sin offering) *5 ONLY IT IS AN UP OFFERING teaches us that only valid UP offerings may have their organs lie on the altar. (An invalid UP offering may not have its organs lie on the altar) |
#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc.2003, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#