lashi-Is-Simple Mailing List VISIT the RASHI DATABASE archives AT http://www.RashiYomi.com/ Surfing the Talmudic Seas (C) RashiYomi Incorporated, 2005 Written by Dr Russell Jay Hendel Volume 29 Number 20 For the WORD QUALITY HTML VERSION click here ----------------------------------- http://www.Rashiyomi.com/h29n20.htm ----------------------------------- Produced May 13, 2006 |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
| |||
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU HAVE | WHAT SHOULD YOU READ | SECTION COLOR | |
Only 2-3 mintues | SUCCINT SUMMARY | BROWN | |
Only 5-8 minutes | LISTS | BROWN/BEIGE/BLUE | |
Maybe 20-30 minutes | BIG FOOTNOTE SECTION | GREEN SECTION | |
Time to do research | SUMMARY OVERVIEWS*2 | Newsletter Bottom | |
|
|||
*1 FIXED WIDTH FONTS are needed for the TEXT version For the HTML version you do not need to reset the browser For html or PDF version visit http://www.Rashiyomi.com/ris.htm *2 Each digest has two summary overviews on bottom: - LIGHTNING SUMMARIES (List of lists in this issue) - OVERVIEW (List of Rashis covered in this issue) |
*#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc., 2006, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#*#*#
VERSE: Lv25-53a
RASHIS COVERED: Lv25-53a Lv25-09b Lv25-43a Lv23-24a
Lv23-08d Lv23-36b Lv23-13a Lv13-13b
Lv13-13c
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||
SUCCINCT SUMMARY ---------------- Rashi frequently makes powerful inferences from - the ALIGNMENT, - that is, the word by word comparison, of almost identical verses.The minor variations between these almost similar verses suggests nuances and differences or even meaning. We call this the Rashi rule of ALIGNMENT -When Rashi identifies two cases from the ALIGNMENT we call this the Rashi subrule of TWO CASES -When Rashi infers nuances from the variations between the almost similar verses (or verse phrases) we call this the Rashi subrule of NUANCES. -When Rashi infers MEANING from the ALIGNMENT of almost identical phrases we call this the Rashi SUBRULE of MEANING. EXAMPLE Lv25-43a ---------------- Note the differences in the following ALIGNED verses --------------------------------------------------------------- - Lv25-43a JEWISH OWNER:Don't work him like an animal - Lv25-53a NON JEW ONWER:Don't work him like an animal VISIBLY - Differs *1 *2 *1 --------------------------------------------------------------- First some background. The Hebrew word Pay-Resh-Caph which roughly means EXCESSIVELY has the ETYMOLOGY LIKE(Kaph) an ANIMAL(PAR). Rashi explains this as referring to making someone work FOR THE SAKE OF MAKING HIM WORK,that is WORK WITHOUT a GOAL. Typical examples are - WARM ME WATER (Prohibited if he doesnt need water) or - WORK TILL I return (Prohibited) (There is no goal here) vs - WORK THIS FIELD (Permitted)(This is goal specific). Now let us return to the ALIGNED verses. As can be seen most of the text (*2) is identical--however the only difference is that the formulation of the abuse prohibition to a NON-JEWISH OWNER is a prohibition on VISIBLE abuse. Hence the law - Courts can intefer if a Jewish owner abuses a slave privately They can enter premises to investigate allegations of abuse - Courts do NOT investigate Non-Jewish owners but do stop public abuse (Things out in the open) LIST343q summarizes this ALIGNMENT Very important comments about the study of Rashi are made in the footnotes to this list. EXAMPLE Lv25-09b ---------------- The following two verses require SHOFAR BLOWING - Lv25-09b Pass a SHOFAR TERUAH BLAST on Yom Kippur Jubilee - Lv23-24a (on Rosh Hashana-New Year) have a BLAST MEMORIAL In a previous posting http://www.Rashiyomi.com/Lv25-09b we showed how the REPETITION --- DAY OF ATONEMENT---10th DAY-- creates emphasis---always blow on the DAY OF ATONEMENT even if it falls on Shabbath. By comparing the two ALIGNED verses we infer the additional Rashi comment on Lv25-09b ---------------------------------------------------- - Jubilee shofar blowing overrides the Sabbath (we learn this from the EMPHASIS of REPETITION) - New Year Shofar may be a MEMORIAL --- Ordinarily we actually blow the Shofar --- If it falls on Shabbath we only Remember the Shofar, Rams horn, by reciting verses on Shofar ----------------------------------------------------- More comments are made by Rashi but I believe the above explanations and ALIGNMENT suffice for now. See the lists below for further comments LIST343r summarizes this ALIGNMENT EXAMPLE: Lv23-08d Lv23-36b -------------------------- Notice the ALIGNMENT of the following verses ------------------------------------------------------------------- - Lv23-08d 7th of Passover is a holiday no JOB PROFESSIONS are done - Ex12-16 7th of Passover is a Holiday no PROFESSIONS are done ------------------------------------------------------------------- Notice the extra word JOB, in Lv23-08d---hence the Rashi ----------------------------------------- - JOB has a connotation of FOR MONEY - PROFESSIONAL connotes more the quality of the work Hence we infer that PROFESSIONAL activities are prohibited on the Holiday whether or not they involve loss of money. That is, whether they are your JOB or simply a PROFESSIONAL ACT you did. ----------------------------------------- LIST309s below summarizes this argument. EXAMPLE: Lv23-13a Lv23-13b Lv23-13c ------------------------------------ Every offering has an accompanying LIBATION offering The specifications of the LIBATION OFFERINGS are spelled out in Nu15. Nu15-04:05 explains that the libation offering for any lamb offering consists of - a Minchah libation - 1/10 flour (Solid measures) - 1/3 log of oil (liquid measures) - 1/3 hin of wine (liquid measures) Lv23-13 spells out the LIBATION offering for a particular offering--the OMER offering - it is also call a Minchah Libation - it has 2/10 flour (vs 1/10 flour for Other lamb offerings) - No measure of oil is specified - 1/3 hin of wine Rashi's 3 comments reflect the fact that this is the only time in the whole Torah that an offering has DIFFERENT libations ----------------------------------------- Even though the amount of flour is doubled - (2 tenths vs 1 tenth) nevertheless - it is still called a LIBATION offering - the amount of wine and oil offered is the same ------------------------------------------ As can be seen here Rashi's major point is the comparison arising from the alignment. LIST314j below summarizes this argument. | ||
ITEM | DETAIL | |
RASHI RULE CLASS: | ALIGNMENT | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS | NUANCES | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #11 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST309q | |
LIST OF | Verses prohibiting slave abuse(Jew-NonJew) | |
---------------------- | --------------------------------------- | |
SEE BELOW | LIST309r | |
LIST OF | Verses requiring SHOFAR blasts | |
---------------------- | --------------------------------------- | |
SEE BELOW | LIST309s | |
LIST OF | Verses prohibiting work on holidays | |
---------------------- | --------------------------------------- | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS | 2 CASES | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #10 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST314j | |
List of verses with | Libation offerings--omer vs ordinary |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||||||
List of verses with Libation offerings--omer vs ordinary | ||||||
Discussion | Source | Name | Flour | Oil | Wine | |
General Lamb Libation | Nu15-04:05 | Minchah | 1 | 1/4 | 1/4 | |
Omer Lamb Libation | Lv23-13 | Minchah | 2 | --- | 1/4 | |
Differs | *1 | *2 | *3 | *4 | ||
Notes | ||||||
----- | ||||||
*1 Both verses refer t | o the libatio | ns as ITS | MINCH | AH | ||
Rashi points out that | despite the d | ifferent | ||||
measures (see footnote | #2) they are | both lib | ations | |||
Although the FLOUR mea | sure is diffe | rent, nev | erthel | ess | ||
the NAME, OIL measures | , and WINE me | asure are | all t | he sa | me | |
(Rashi: Lv23-13a) | ||||||
*2 ONE tenth for GENER | AL offerings; | TWO tent | hs for | OMER | ||
This is the only insta | nce in the Bi | ble where | the | |||
GENERAL libations ment | ioned in Numb | ers are D | IFFERE | NT | ||
for a particular offer | ing | |||||
(Rashi: Lv23-13b) | ||||||
*3 The OMER offering v | erse does not | specify | an OIL | amou | nt | |
We therefore assume it | is the same | as in all | libat | ions. | ||
The measure is 1/3 a L | OG (A liquid | measure) | ||||
Although the FLOUR mea | sure is diffe | rent, nev | erthel | ess | ||
the NAME, OIL measures | , and WINE me | asure are | all t | he sa | me | |
(Rashi: Lv23-13c) | ||||||
*4 One quarter HIN (Li | quid measure) | for the | wine l | ibati | on. | |
Although the FLOUR mea | sure is diffe | rent, nev | erthel | ess | ||
the NAME, OIL measures | , and WINE me | asure are | all t | he sa | me | |
(Rashi: Lv23-13c) |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||||||
LIST OF Verses prohibiting work on holidays | ||||||
VERSE | Phrase1 | Phrase 2 | #3 | Phrase #4 | Phrase#5 | |
Lv23-08d | 7th of Passover | is a holiday | no JOB | PROFESSIONS | are done | |
Ex12-16 | 7th of Passover | is a Holiday | no | PROFESSIONS | are done | |
Differs | *1 | *2 | *3 | *4 | *5 | |
|
||||||
*1 The same *2 The same *3 Notice the extra word JOB, in Lv23-08d---hence the Rashi - JOB has a connotation of FOR MONEY - PROFESSIONAL connotes more the quality of the work Hence we infer that PROFESSIONAL activities are prohibited on the Holiday whether or not they involve loss of money. That is, whether they are your JOB or simply a PROFESSIONAL ACT you did. *4 The same *5 The same |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||||
LIST OF Verses prohibiting slave abuse(Jew-NonJew) | ||||
VERSE | TOPIC | Phrase 1 | PHRASE2 | |
Lv25-43a | JEWISH OWNER | Don't work him like an animal*3 | ||
Lv25-53a | NON JEW ONWER | Don't work him like an animal | VISIBLY | |
Differs | *1 | *2 | *1 | |
|
||||
*1 The only difference is that the formulation of abuse prohibition to a NON-JEWISH OWNER is on VISIBLE Abuse. Hence the law - Courts can intefer if a Jewish owner abuses a slave privately They can enter premises to investigate allegations of abuse - Courts do NOT investigate Non-Jewish owners but do stop public abuse (Things out in the open) *2 As can be seen most of the text is identical *3 First some background. The Hebrew word Pay-Resh-Caph which roughly means EXCESSIVELY has the ETYMOLOGY LIKE(Kaph) an ANIMAL(PAR). Rashi explains this as referring to making someone work FOR THE SAKE OF MAKING HIM WORK,that is WORK WITHOUT a GOAL. Typical examples are - WARM ME WATER (Prohibited) but he doesnt need water or - WORK TILL 5 (Prohibited) (There is no goal here) vs - WORK THIS FIELD (Permitted)(This is goal specific). | ||||
|
||||
*10 An important point about studying Rashi is the following -------------------------------------------------------- Many people use the approach of Dr Boncheck and Dr Leibowitz According to this approach Rashi was BOTHERED by the extra word DONT WORK HIM LIKE AN ANIMAL **VISIBLY**. Alternatively Rashi had a QUESTION and INQUIRY on what the extra word VISIBLY is doing in the verse (The verse DONT WORK HIM LIKE AN ANIMAL is clear without the extra word). The approach on this email group is slightly different. We are not bothered by extra words per se. Indeed, it might be a matter of Hebrew style that sentences require certain words which are logically extra. In other words we reject the idea that the Divinity of the Torah is EQUATED with the idea that the SMALLEST NUMBER OF WORDS IS USED. However when the EXTRA WORD emerges from an ALIGNMENT we feel justified in Rashi-ing the verse. That is - Boncheck/Leibowitz believe Rashi is commenting on the EXTRA WORD (The verse LOGICALLY reads fine without it) - Hendel believes Rashi is commenting on the DIFFERENCE in the ALIGNED verses. Our position is that REQUIRING an ALIGNMENT before explaining a Rashi comment makes the Rashi comment punchier and clearer. We don't believe the EXTRA WORD approach by itself is well defined. This is only a difference in approach. It is not a difference in content. Both Hendel, Leibowitz and Boncheck explain all Midrashim as logical and following exegetical rules. They however differ in the rules used. ------------------------------------------------------ |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||||
LIST OF Verses requiring SHOFAR blasts | |||||
VERSE | Topic | #1 | Phrase #2 | Phrase #3 | |
Lv25-09b | Yom Kippur | Pass | a SHOFAR | TERUAH | |
Lv23-24a | New Year | Have | a MEMORIAL of | TERUAH | |
Differs | *1 | *2 | *1 | *4 | |
Notes | |||||
----- | |||||
*1 | |||||
In a prev | ious postin | g http:// | www.Rashiyomi. | com/Lv25-09b | |
we showed | how the RE | PETITION | --- DAY OF ATO | NEMENT---10th DAY-- | |
creates e | mphasis---a | lways blo | w on the DAY O | F ATONEMENT even | |
if it fal | ls on Shabb | ath. | |||
By compar | ing the two | ALIGNED | verses we infe | r the Rashi | |
additiona | l Rashi com | ment on L | v25-09b | ||
--------- | ----------- | --------- | -------------- | --------- | |
- Jubilee | shofar blo | wing over | rides the Sabb | ath | |
(we learn | this from | the EMPHA | SIS of REPETIT | ION) | |
- New Yea | r Shofar ma | y be a ME | MORIAL | ||
--- Ordin | arily we ac | tually bl | ow the Shofar | ||
--- If it | falls on S | habbath w | e only REmembe | r the | |
Shofar, R | ams horn, b | y recitin | g verses on Sh | ofar*10 | |
--------- | ----------- | --------- | -------------- | ---------- | |
*2 Rashi | does not co | mment on | this differenc | e. | |
I present | ly dont kno | w a reaso | n. | ||
*3 This i | s the same | in both v | erses | ||
|
|||||
*10 I have not gotten into the relevant issue of whether this Rashi comment is intrinsic to the text (are the laws Biblically ordained) or are they pegs of Rabbinic laws. Suffice it to say that it is possible that the Biblical requirement on New Year is to REMEMBER the SHOFAR say by reciting verses. Alternatively we can EQUALLY read the verse ------------------------------------------ a MEMORIAL BY SHOFAR BLOWING ------------------------------------------ indicating that we SHOULD always blow the Shofar and it is a memorial for the Binding of Isaac. The prohibition of Blowing on Shabbath would then be Rabbinic (lest a person carry it publicly by accident). The goal of this email list is not to resolve this Talmudic controversy--rather we point out how the ALIGNMENT sheds light on it and its alternative. |
*#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc., 2006, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#*#*#
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
Lighting summary of Rashis with emphasis on Rashi rules*10 | |||
# | LIST | BRIEF SUMMARY OF RASHI EMPHASIZING USE OF RASHI RULES | |
11 | 309q | JEW:Don't abuse; NON JEW: Don't abuse VISIBLY(Courts dont check) | |
11 | 309r | JUBILEE: shofar Blast; NEW YEAR: Blast memorial--Verses on Sbbth | |
11 | 309s | No PROFESSIONS vs No JOB PROFESSIONS(with/without money | |
10 | 314j | Omer has 2 tenths flour vs 1 tenth flour for its libation | |
|
|||
| |||
|
|||
*10 The explanation of the list should be clear - The first column gives the NUMBER of the RASHI RULE used All Rashi rules may be found with examples at http://wwww.Rashiyomi.com/workbook.htm - The second column gives the LIST ID (eg LIST210z) which contains many examples of a particular Rashi technique and includes the example presented in the third column - The third column gives a lightning summary of the Rashi with particular emphasis on the Rashi rule used. All lists may be found at http://www.Rashiyomi.com/lists.htm |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
| |||
VERSE | RULE | BRIEF DESCRIPTION | |
======== | =============== | ===================================== | |
Lv25-53a | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv25-09b | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv25-43a | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv23-24a | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv23-08d | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv23-36b | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv23-13a | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv13-13b | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
Lv13-13c | ALIGNMENT | DONT ABUSE vs DONT ABUSE VISIBLY | |
--------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------- |
*#*#*# (C) RashiYomi Inc., 2006, Dr. Hendel, President #*#*#*#*#