LIST108L (C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04
|
PARAGRAPH structure of Dt33-08:11 a)Fights Gods battle b)Torah
|
TEXT OF VERSES
|
Stage
|
OTHER VERSES
|
CONCERNING*1 Levi he said
|
Prophetic
|
|
HIS*1 pious deserve prophecy*2
|
Prophetic
|
cf Nu27-21*2
|
--------------------------
|
-------------
|
---------------------
|
Doesnt complain:*3 lack of food
|
Physical
|
Ex17-01:07 Nu20-07:13
|
--------------------------
|
-------------
|
---------------------
|
Ready to break family ties*4
|
Social
|
cf Ex32-26:27
|
When watching Gods word/convenant
|
Social
|
cf Ex20-02:04,Ex32-01
|
--------------------------
|
-------------
|
---------------------
|
The will Teach the Jews*5
|
Intellectual
|
cf Dt17-09,Ma02-07
|
They will symbolically instruct*6
|
Intellectual
|
cf Nu18-01:07
|
--------------------------
|
-------------
|
---------------------
|
God blesses him militarily*7
|
Political
|
cf P069-24
|
He pulverizes*8 his enemies
|
Political
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
COMMENTS
|
*1 - The Hebrew leter LAMED (as a prefix letter) means TO
- Here Rashi interprets it as meaning CONCERNING (=TOWARDS)
Rashi does so because the 3rd person is used in
the next verselet
-------------------------------------
HIS Pious = Levi, deserve Prophecy
-------------------------------------
Hence the Rashis
----------------
(Dt33-08b) The word HIS refers to GOD
(Dt33-08a) The word LAMED means CONCERNING
Here Rashi is assisted by the GRAMMAR rule
*2 The verse literally says
------------------------------------
His pious deserve the URIM and TUMIM
------------------------------------
We interpret
the URIM and TUMIM as meaning PROPHECY since
Nu27-21 explicitly identifies the function of
the URIM and TUMIM as PROPHETIC INSIGHT.
Here Rashi uses the METONOMY principle--that is
Rashi interprets URIM and TUMIM by a concept--prophecy--
RELATED to it. Rashi also uses the OTHER VERSE principle.
*3 The Biblical verse mentions the incidents at the cities
of MASAH and MERIVAH. The OTHER VERSES cited show that the
nation complained about lack of food and water. Levi is not
explicitly mentioned however because of the POETRY principle
which allows overall paragraph structure to indicate new
meaning even if that new meaning is not explicitly indicated
by the GRAMMAR and WORDS, Rashi interprets
----------------------------------------------------
The nation complained about food and water
Levi however did not complain
----------------------------------------------------
Again such READ IN meanings are common in poetry. Using
this READ IN principle we can also understand Rashi's
2nd comment
----------------------------------------------
He FOUGHT for HIM (God) AT MERIVAH
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Rashi: When Moses said
- - - - - - - - - -
Listen You rebellious ones
- - - - - - - - - -
Levi retorted
- - - - - - - - - -
Were Aaron and Miryam rebellious?
- - - - - - - - - -
thereby showing that Moses lost his temper
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
----------------------------------------------
We need not perceive this Rashi as indicating an EXHAUSTION
OF MEANING..that would be silly...we have no record of Levi
making such statements...Rather we see this Rashi as
indicating a POSSIBILITY--something that could have happened
which would show the general theme that Levi was loyal to God
As we indicated many times the proper method to read
POETRY is to try and find pithy examples illustrating the
verses general theme. The essence of poetry interpretation
is to have
- ones eye on extreme examples but
- ones heart on thematic meaning
The above is the proper attitude by which to
judge and interpret Rashis
*4 The OTHER VERSES uses almost identical language and shows that
- When the Jews violated the first commandment (No Idolatry)
- at the incident of the Golden calf
- Levi clung to God
- Levi was ready to forsake family ties and
- Execute brothers/family who worship idols
These other verses show SOCICAL INDEPENDENCE
*5 The OTHER VERSES indicate that the PRIESTS/LEVITES were to
serve as teachers of the Jewish people.(These verses are
brought by me, not Rashi. But they seem in the spirit of
the other Rashis)
*6 I cite an OTHER VERSE showing that the PRIESTS / LEVITES
were in charge of the OFFERING procedures which gave
symbolic instruction.
Rashi cites differently. The verse literally says
-------------------------------------
They will place ALL offerings on your altar
-------------------------------------
Rashi could have cited Lv06-15 which refers to the PRIESTLY
FLOUR OFFERING as an ALL offering since it is WHOLLY (ALL)
offered on the ALTAR.
Rashi instead refers to the UP offering which is also
WHOLLY (ALL) offered on the altar even though this language
is not used
We however should not get bogged down in Rashi's associations
We should see the OVERALL picture...the LEVITE/PRIEST teaches
thru the OFFERINGS. Rashi simply gives pithy examples
consistent with the theme.
*7 Rashi interprets the verselet
-----------------------------------
God blesses him militarily
-----------------------------------
to refer to the war of the Chashmonaim.
Many scholars read this Rashi incorrectly
- Rashi is not EXHAUSTING or IDENTIFYING the meaning of the
verse with the Chashmonaim war.
- Rather Rashi is ILLUSTRATING the meaning of the verse
- In other words the verse means that
------------------------------
LEVITES ARE MILITARILY STRONG
------------------------------
- Rashi would like to use an OTHER VERSE to support this
- But there are no OTHER VERSES
- There are no Biblical wars with Levites
- So Rashi brings an historical incidenct, the
Chasmonaim war where the Levites were victorious
- Rashi's goal is simply to ILLUSTRATE the verse's
general meaning.
Rashi also emphasizes that the Levites had a strong
military hand despite their small numbers.
Finally Rashi interprets MILITARILY STRONG, POLITICALLY
-------------------------------------
Those who dispute the priesthood will
perish (Like Korach during his rebellion)
--------------------------------------
*8 Here Rashi uses the ALIGNMENT and OTHER VERSE method
to explain the verse meaning.
The verse literally says
-----------------------------------------------
PULVERIZE loins uprisers
enemies shall not rise
-----------------------------------------------
Rashi using the ALIGNMENT method rearranges the
verse to clarify the meaning (Dt33-11a,Dt33-11b)
------------------------------------------------
PULVERIZE [the] loins [of the] uprisers
NO RISE [for] [the ] enemies
------------------------------------------------
The metaphor PULVERIZE LOINS is similar to the metaphor
RATTLE LOINS in P069-24.
|