Rashi-Is-Simple Mailing List VISIT the RASHI DATABASE archives AT http://www.RashiYomi.com/ Surfing the Talmudic Seas (C) Dr. Russell Jay Hendel, 2006 Volume 32 Number 5 1st Published / Produced Dec 27, 2006 Individual Digest Jan 16, 2007 |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
| |||
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU HAVE | WHAT SHOULD YOU READ | SECTION COLOR | |
Only 2-3 mintues | SUCCINT SUMMARY | BROWN | |
Only 5-8 minutes | LISTS | BROWN/BEIGE/BLUE | |
Maybe 20-30 minutes | BIG FOOTNOTE SECTION | GREEN SECTION | |
Time to do research | SUMMARY OVERVIEWS*2 | Newsletter Bottom | |
|
|||
*1 FIXED WIDTH FONTS are needed for the TEXT version For the HTML version you do not need to reset the browser For html or PDF version visit http://www.Rashiyomi.com/ris.htm *2 Each digest has two summary overviews on bottom: - LIGHTNING SUMMARIES (List of lists in this issue) - OVERVIEW (List of Rashis covered in this issue) |
#*#*#*# (C)#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*2006, Dr. Hendel,#*#*#*#*#*##*#*#*#*#
VERSE: Ex03-19b
RASHIS COVERED: Ex03-19b Ex02-15c Ex10-24a Ex13-12a Ex11-08b
Ex12-11a Ex12-13c Ex12-23a Ex14-31a Ex12-23b
Ex10-15a Ex02-16b Ex03-16a
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||
SUCCINCT SUMMARY ---------------- One of Rashis 10 main goals is to give the meaning of words the same way the dictionary gives meaning. We call this the Rashi method of WORD MEANING. All languages allow words to acquire NEW MEANINGS. Rashi frequently used a universal principle of all languages---METONOMY. METONOMY refers to the capacity to name an item by a related item (such as naming a PEOPLE, Americans, by the LAND they live in, America) Some standard METONOMYS name words by their - FORM (e.g. the PENTAGON) - FUNCTION (e.g. the UNITED NATIONS) - FEEL (e.g. HARDship) - SUBSTANCE (e.g. a GLASS, or GLASSES) We call this the FFF (Form Function Feel) principle. The examples below illustrate these techniques. Throughout these example I cite similar IDIOMS in English. Exploration of English Dictionaries and Theosaurii may be found at http://www.dictionary.com/. Some of the examples of English usage presented below come from this excellent website. To illustrate how to use this web reference: If I say TO GIVE can mean TO ALLOW then you - type the word GIVE - in the SEARCH BOX - of the above DICTIONARY website - and click the THEOSAURUS - and click SEARCH. Among the SYNONYMS for GIVE presented by the THEASAURUS is TO ALLOW. Hence Rashi's comment that TO GIVE means to ALLOW is identical with English idiomatic usage. This idiomatic sharing between the two languages enhances the meaningfulness of Rashi. EXAMPLES 1,2: Ex03-19b Ex12-23b TO GIVE=TO ALLOW -------------------------------------------- - A GIFT refers to a transfer of OWNERSHIP of an OBJECT (Without pay). That is the RECIPIENT may now USE the object. - To ALLOW/PERMIT refers to allow doing an ACTIVITY that formerly was prohibited. In other words GIFTS or GOOD EXAMPLES of PERMISSION and ALLOWANCES. Hence the translation GIFT=ALLOW is an example of SYNECHDOCHE. We see this in Ex03-19b -------------------------------------------- And the King of Egypt will not ALLOW [literally GIVE] you to go; not even with a might hand -------------------------------------------- Similarly Rashi interprets Ex12-23b ------------------------------------------------- And God will go out in Egypt and see the blood on the doorposts ...and will not ALLOW the destroyer to come to your house to destroy ------------------------------------------------- In English also TO GIVE means to ALLOW as e.g. in The Judge did not GIVE the permit. EXAMPLE 3: Ex02-15c To SIT=To DWELL ----------------------------------- In Hebrew the word SIT also means to DWELL. The idea is that SITTING (vs STANDING) is a GOOD EXAMPLE (SYNECHDOCHE!) of staying in a place for a while (and hence the meaning TO DWELL). Hence Rashi translates Ex02-15c ------------------------------------------ Moses fled from Pharoh...he DWELT in Midyan and DWELT by the wells ------------------------------------------- EXAMPLE 4: Ex10-24a To STAND = to REMAIN ---------------------------------------- In Hebrew as in English to STAND on your position means to REMAIN in your position. Here STANDING (vs walking) is a GOOD EXAMPLE (SYNECHDOCHE!) of REMAINING IN PLACE. (cf the English "He STANDS for democracy.") EXAMPLE 5: Ex11-08b WALKERS=FOLLOWers ----------------------------------------- In Hebrew as in English FOLLOWers are named by a typical GOOD EXAMPLE (SYNECHDOCHE!) of following: Namely PHYSICALLY walking and following the leader. In ENGLISH we call the people FOLLOWERS while in Hebrew we call the people WALKERS. In each case the GENERAL idea of FOLLOWING ADVICE and GUIDANCE is **EXEMPLIFIED** by physically FOLLOWING or WALKING after a LEADER. EXAMPLE 6: Ex12-11a BELTED=prepared/Energetically -------------------------------------------------- Rashi explains that -------------------------------------- TO BELT means to PREPARE for the road -------------------------------------- Clearly a GOOD EXAMPLE (SYNECHDOCHE!) of preparing for a trek is to put on your hiking belt. Similarly a GOOD EXAMPLE of preparation in war is to GIRD your utility belt. In English we have similar IDIOMS. - To GIRD means to PREPARE - To BELT a SONG means to SING IT ENERGETICALLY EXAMPLES 7,8: Ex12-13c Ex12-23a To SKIP=To OMIT ----------------------------------------------- In Hebrew as in Enlish To SKIP something can mean to OMIT it. Here SKIPPING is a GOOD EXAMPLE (SYNECHDOCHE!) of AVOIDANCE and OMISSION. Hence the Rashi on Ex12-13c which describes how --------------------------------------------- God will punish the Egyptian firstborn but SKIP over the Jewish firstborn --------------------------------------------- Rashi comments ----------------------- To SKIP means to JUDGE ------------------------ We would interpret Rashi as follows --------------------------------------------- A Judge who SKIPS someone has OMITTED punishment and forgiven him of judgement --------------------------------------------- Although Rashi connects SKIP with FORGIVE we think the primary driving force of Rashi is that SKIP means TO OMIT and hence OMISSION IN JUDGEMENT is FORGIVENESS Such an approach to Rashi is intuitive and consistent with IDIOMS in other languages. Here we have used the technique of MEDIATING VARIABLES to resolve the problematic Rashi which connects SKIP with FORGIVE. We have suggested the more plausible alternative that - SKIP connects with OMIT and - OMISSION in a context of Judgement connects with FORGIVENESS EXAMPLE 9: Ex13-12a ------------------- In Hebrew as in English to PASS TO someone idiomatically can mean to ENDOW. Here, PASSING TO is a typical gesture(SYNECHDOCHE!) of ENDOWMENT. Consequently Rashi translates Ex12-13 as follows ----------------------------------------------- And you shall ENDOW to God all first born; and all first born animals that are yours, the males, belong to God ----------------------------------------------- EXAMPLE 10: Ex14-31a -------------------- Rashi explains that the phrase GREAT HAND is an IDIOM meaning GREAT MIGHT. I would go a step further-- citing Rav Hirsch on Psalms 8 I would say GREAT HAND in Hebrew is like GREAT HANDIWORK in English and connotes ACCOMPLISHMENT. Here ACCOMPLISHMENT refers not only to expenditure of ENERGY (MIGHT) but also SKILL and CRAFTSMANSHIP Hence Rashi could translate Ex14-31a as --------------------------------------------- The Jews saw the GREAT CRAFTSMANSHIP of what God did in Egypt and they reveered God and they had faith in God and Moses his servant --------------------------------------------- Here CRAFTSMANSHIP (Connoting both ENERGY and ARTISAN SKILL) are accomplished principally thru the hand and hence this idiom is another example of naming by a typically good example (SYNECHDOCHE). EXAMPLE 11: Ex03-16a ------------------- Rashi explains that the word ELDERS can also mean the LEADERS, MAYORS, SCHOLARS of the community. Here Rashi uses SYNECHDOCHE since the ELDERS are TYPICAL GOOD EXAMPLES of MAYORS and LEADERS since generally a statesman must have acquired alot of experience. There are of course exceptions but the whole point of SYNECHDOCHE is simply to take a good example. Rashi does derive that ELDERS = LEADERS from logic and OTHER VERSES. However we believe that the SYNECHDOCHE argument has broader application. EXAMPLE 12: Ex02-16b ------------------- The Hebrew root Resh-Hey-Tet means - Water Troughs - above-ground bridges connecting two buildings(So07-06) Here both the above-ground bridge and the water trough have the same FORM--a long rectangular object. EXAMPLE 13: Ex10-15a ------------------- The Hebrew root YUD-RESH-KUPH means GREEN. Hence it refers to VERDURE, the GREEN covering of meadows. Here the meadow covering is named by its FORM and COLOR similar to the English idiom "ORANGE dress" which names a COLOR by an object with that COLOR. Note that in English also VERDURE refers to the VERDENT (Green) covering of a MEADOW. LIST871z presents these and other IDIOMS based on metonomy, synechdoche, and FFF. | ||
ITEM | DETAIL | |
RASHI RULE CLASS: | WORD MEANING | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS | NEW MEANINGS | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #7 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST871z | |
List of idioms using | METONOMY/SYNECHDOCHE(Meaning by relation) |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||||
List of idioms using METONOMY/SYNECHDOCHE(Meaning by relation) LIST871z continues LIST871d LIST871c LIST871b LIST871a | ||||
VERSE | TEXT OF VERSE | METONOMY | METHOD USED | |
Dt22-06b | Mother ON eggs | NESTING mother | METONOMY | |
Dt28-67a | WHO WILL GIVE | Oh I WISH(someone gives) | METONOMY | |
Dt28-67b | WHO WILL GIVE | Oh I WISH(someone gives) | METONOMY | |
Dt28-47a | ALOT OF ALL | Sufficiency | METONOMY | |
Dt28-07b | SEVEN paths | MANY paths | METONOMY | |
Dt04-32b | 1 END OF HEAVN | NATIONS at HORIZON | METONOMY*14 | |
Dt04-08a | RIGHTEOUS laws | ...done by the RIGHTEOUS | METONOMY | |
------- | ------------- | ----------------------- | ------------ | |
Ex13-12a | PASS TO God | ENDOW to GOD | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex03-19b | To GIVE to go | to ALLOW to Go | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex03-23b | To GIVE to go | to ALLOW to Go | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex02-15c | To SIT in Mdyn | To DWELL in MDYN | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex10-24a | will STAND | will REMAIN | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex11-08b | Your WALKERS | your FOLLOWers | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex12-13c | To SKIP them | To OMIT them | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex12-23a | To SKIP doors | To OMIT judging houses | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex12-11a | To BELT/GIRD | To PREPARE | SNYECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex03-16a | Elders | Leaders,mayors,.. | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Lv02-11a | HONEY | SWEET*1 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Lv21-21c | BREAD | FOOD*1 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Nu08-02c | Candellabrah | Central Staff | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Nu09-15a | Tent Tablets | Whole Temple*11 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex31-21c | Tent Tablets | Whole Temple*11 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Lv18-03a | Egyptian-like | Sexually perverse*10 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Lv18-03b | CanaaniteLike | Sexually perverse*10 | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
Ex14-31a | great HAND | CRAFTMANSHIP,MIGHT | SYNECHDOCHE*1 | |
------- | ------------- | ----------------------- | ------------ | |
Nu14-09b | Our Bread | Piece of cake(Easy) | Metonomy*2 | |
Nu10-31d | Our eyes | Gleam of our eye(Good) | Metonomy*2 | |
Nu14-11a | Till WHERE | Till WHEN*4 | Metonomy*2 | |
Lv18-09b | OUT BIRTH | OUT of WEDLOCK | Metonomy*2 | |
Nu11-20c | Out of nose | disgusted*12 | Metonomy*2 | |
Nu09-20b | Numbered days | Small number of days | Metonomy*2 | |
------- | ------------- | ----------------------- | ------------ | |
Ex10-15a | VERDURE | Verdent (Green) | FFF-Form*3 | |
Ex02-16b | Trough | high rise bridge connect | FFF-Form*3 | |
Nu08-16b | SproutFromWomb | birth*13 | FFF-Form*3 | |
Nu20-22b | Mount Mountain | Mount on top of mountain | FFF-Form*3 | |
Nu04-14a | Frighteners | Coal rakers | FFF-Feeling*3 | |
Nu04-14c | Barren | Sweep cleam | FFF-Function*3 | |
-------- | Pentagon | Pentagon Institution | FFF-Form*3 | |
-------- | U.N. | U.N. Institution | FFF-Function*3 | |
Gn14-17b | FLAT VALLEY | Stadium | FFF-Form*3 | |
Gn21-20a | BOW RAINS | Archer | FFF-Form*3*4 | |
|
||||
*1 An example of SYNECHDOCHE--naming the whole by the part *2 An example of METONOMY--naming by something related *3 An example of naming by either - Form (eg Pentagon) - Function (e.g UN) - Feel (e.g. Hardship) We call this the FFF rule. *4 RULE ---- * ALeph nun hey = WHERE * UNTIL Aleph Nun Hey= until WHEN *5 In the case of ARCHER, RAIN OF BOW, refers to the FORM of the ACTIVITY of the ARCHER (not to the FORM of the ARCHER himself). A rapid set of BOW SHOOTS resembles IN FORM a torrential rain. | ||||
|
||||
*10 Rashi: ----------------------------------------------- Since generally sexually-perverse acts are called EGYPTIAN-LIKE and CANAANITE LIKE we infer that EGYPT and CANAAN were exemplary in sexual perversity. ----------------------------------------------- Here Rashi uses the SYNECHDOCHE principle to explain the reason for naming sexual perversity as EGYPT-LIKE and CANAANITE-LIKE. *11 For reasons of space we have abbreviated. Nu09-15c literally translated states ----------------------------- SANCTUARY FOR TENT OF TABLETS ----------------------------- Ex31-21c literally translated states -------------------------------- The Sanctuary of Tablets -------------------------------- The following terms all refer to the Temple -------------------------------------------- * Sanctuary * Sanctuary of Tablets * Sanctuary for the Tent of Tablets * Sanctuary of the tent of Meeting -------------------------------------------- While Rashi explains the details of some of these terms it seems reasonable to simply view them all as IDIOMS. Some further comments on the terms are presented below. Technically the literal Hebrew term is -------------------------------------- * Sanctuary of TESTIMONY -------------------------------------- However the TABLETS with the 10 COMMANDMENTS are called the TESTIMONY (See Ex31-18 or Ex25-16)Hence we have translated this phrase as the ------------------------------- * Sanctuary of Tablets ------------------------------- The temple is called the --------------------------------- * Sanctuary of Meeting --------------------------------- because God designates the Temple as a meeting place for Prophecy (Cf. Ex25-22) *12 The verse states ---------------------------- until it comes out of your nose and becomes strange ---------------------------- Rashi translates the whole item as meaning DISGUSTING. Clearly this is an example of NEW MEANINGS. *13 Here are a few uses of Pay-Tet-Resh --------------------------------------- * SPROUTING buds (SPROUTING) 1K06-19 --------------------------------------- * SPROUTING(Leaving) from before King (1S19-10) * SPROUTING (releasing) water (Pr17-14) * SPROUTING from Womb (Nu08-16) --------------------------------------- We clearly have here a naming by FORM. *14 Rashi gives an alternative explanation --------------------------------------- This refers to Adam whose stature extended from ONE OF HEAVEN TO THE OTHER --------------------------------------- Rashi here unifies both parts of the verse ------------------------------------------ - go back in history to ask - ask Adam ------------------------------------------ The statement that ADAM's stature extended from one of heaven to the other simply meant that ADAM like NOACH and ABRAHAM unified the whole world. We metaphorically indicate the impact of such people by using words like GREAT, BIG. The statement ------------------------------------------- Adam's stature extended from one end of the world to the other -------------------------------------------- simply means that -------------------------------------------- Adam's influence extended from one end of the world to the other since he unified the world -------------------------------------------- Here again Rashi identifies a PERSON with the LOCATIONS of his REIGN. |
*#*#*# (C)#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*2006, Dr. Hendel,#*#*#*#*#*##*#*#*#*#
VERSE: Ex10-21a
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | ||
SUCCINCT SUMMARY ---------------- One of Rashi's 10 main goals is explaining word meaning similar to what a dictionary might do. Rashi had 10 vehicles by which to explain word meaning. Rashi will sometimes explain word meaning by methods common to all languages such as naming by FORM, FUNCTION, FEEL etc Today we study naming items by EXAGGERATION, a techniques common to all languages. For example BREAKFAST refers to the day-s first meal; it is the meal where you BREAK your FAST. Similarly the SKY-SCRAPER is pictured as SCRAPING the SKY. Here are some Biblical examples of EXAGGERATION. EXAMPLE 1 Ex10-21a--a FELT DARKNESS ----------------------------------- Verse Ex10-21a states -------------------------------- God said to Moses Waive your hand on the sky and there will be darkness in Egypt and the darkness WILL BE FELT -------------------------------- Rashi comments -------------------------------- The phrase DARKNESS WILL BE FELT is an EXAGGERATION---it simply means that the darkness will be darker than night darkness (When there is some visibility). The darkness will be so great that movement will be inhibited (Because you can't see where you are going) and it will appear as if the darkness is being FELT and preventing movement --------------------------------- LIST972a below summarizes these examples and provides further examples. | ||
ITEM | DETAIL | |
RASHI RULE CLASS: | WORD MEANINGS | |
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS | EXAGGERATION | |
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE | #7 | |
SEE BELOW | LIST972a | |
Words whose meaning | shows exaggeration |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
Words whose meaning shows exaggeration | |||
VERSE | TEXT OF VERSE | CAPPED TERM MEANS.. | |
Ex10-21a | darkness will be FELT | darker than usual | |
Ex21-03a | he comes in his BODY | BODY-ONLY=single | |
Lv19-20a | WINTERED to a man | Engaged vs Married | |
Gn33-13a | Young ON ME | Carry ON SHOULDERS | |
-------- | Skyscraper | Tall building | |
-------- | Breakfast | 1st meal of day | |
-------- | Hear a pin drop | Silence | |
|
|||
*1 EXAGGERATION is also called (possibly with some differences) as BDELYGMIA and HYPERBOLE. But the basic concept of EXAGGERATING is the same |
#*#*#*# (C)#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*2006, Dr. Hendel,#*#*#*#*#*##*#*#*#*#
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
Lighting summary of Rashis with emphasis on Rashi rules*10 | |||
# | LIST | BRIEF SUMMARY OF RASHI EMPHASIZING USE OF RASHI RULES | |
7 | 871z | To GIVE=To ALLOW;to SIT=to DWELL;to STAND=to REMAIN;to SKIP=omit | |
7 | 871z | to PASS=to ENDOW;to BELT=prepare;WALKERS = FOLLOWers;ELDER=LEADE | |
7 | 871z | VERDURE = VERDENT pasture; WATER TROUGH=building connector(shape | |
7 | 972a | NAMING BY EXAGGERATION: FELT darkness means extremely dark | |
|
|||
| |||
|
|||
*10 The explanation of the list should be clear - The first column gives the NUMBER of the RASHI RULE used All Rashi rules may be found with examples at http://wwww.Rashiyomi.com/workbook.htm - The second column gives the LIST ID (eg LIST210z) which contains many examples of a particular Rashi technique and includes the example presented in the third column - The third column gives a lightning summary of the Rashi with particular emphasis on the Rashi rule used. All lists may be found at http://www.Rashiyomi.com/lists.htm |
(C) Dr Hendel, Jan-04 | |||
| |||
VERSE | RULE | BRIEF DESCRIPTION | |
======== | =============== | ===================================== | |
Ex03-19b | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex02-15c | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex10-24a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex13-12a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex11-08b | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex12-11a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex12-13c | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex12-23a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex14-31a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex12-23b | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex10-15a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex02-16b | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex03-16a | NEW MEANINGS | to GIVE=to ALLOW;to STAND=to REMAIN | |
Ex10-21a | WORD MEANINGS | EXAGGERATION:FELT darkness=very drk | |
--------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------- |
#*#*#*# (C) 2000-2006,#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#* Dr Hendel#*#*#*#*#*##*#*#*#