Rashi-Is-Simple Mailing List
VISIT the RASHI DATABASE archives AT
http://www.RashiYom.com/
Surfing the Talmudic Seas
(C) RashiYomi Incorporated, 2000
Written by Dr Russell Jay Hendel
Volume 8 Number 1
Produced Oct 31, 2000
WARNING: USE FIX WIDTH FONTS (eg COURIER (NEW) 10)
WEB ANNOUNCEMENT NEW NEW RASHI YOMI CALENDAR NEW NEW NEW
==============================================================
The RashiYomi Calendar is very popular. Check it out at
http://www.RashiYomi.Com/calendar.htm
READER QUESTIONS RASHI RAMBAN CONTROVERSY ON FLOOD
================
Shraga Sunness, M.D. asks for a defense of the Rashi-Ramban
controversy on the sequence of dates during the flood. As Shraga
notes, the question is not for a defense of RASHI but rather for
a defense of Rashi's SIMPLICITY, since the Rambans argument is
that Rashi arbitrarily uses relative dating with changes in the
base date How can this be defended as simple and natural?
The answer will be in the next issue and will use the advanced
methods we have developed for overall paragraph structure using
Rabbi Ishmaels methods.
READER QUESTIONS
===============
My weekly Shomrey Emunah Rashi class raised numerous valid
objections to my explanations of the Hebrew root AYIN-VUV-DALET
Based on these objections, and also based on the list of meanings
presented by the RADACK I have revised my explanations.
WEEKLY PARSHAH SERIES
=====================
Will be continued Thursday with the discussion of the
chronology of events during the flood
RASHIS COVERED
==============
Dt19-09a We amend our posting of last issue. Rashi & RADACK
have a controversy on The Hebrew word AYIN VUV DALET
According to RADACK AYIN-VUV-DALET means a) CONTINUATION
b) REPETITION c) STILL d) WHILE e) YOUTH. According
to RASHI the fundamental meaning is REPETITION or AGAIN
Rashis covered in this issue
----------------------------
VERSE RULE BRIEF DESCRIPTION
======== ============== ================================
Dt19-09a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn04-25a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn07-04b SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn19-12a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn35-09a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn35-10a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn38-26a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn08-08a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn45-28a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn46-29c SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Nu18-05a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn29-30a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Dt31-02a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Nu19-13c SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn08-22a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Gn29-07a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Lv25-51a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
Ex02-03a SPECIAL WORDS >Ayin-Vuv-Daled< means >AGAIN<
-----------------------------------------------------------------
#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*# (C) Dr Hendel, 2000*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*
RASHI IS SIMPLE
GOALS: To grammatically defend all 8000 Rashis on Chumash.
METHOD:Rashis are defended with LISTS of comparable cases
INTENDED AUDIENCE: Laymen, Academicians, Yeshiva world
COMMENTS,QUESTIONS: EMail to address below
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:If you want to ask anonymously please ask
(UN)SUBSCRIBE: Email to addresses below with "(UN)subscribe"
JOURNAL REFERENCE: Pshat & Drash,TRADITION, Win 1980,R Hendel
NOTATION: eg Gn01-02a refers Genesis, Chapter 1, Verse 2,Rashi a
SPECIALS:...on Parshah,Rambam,Ramban,Pedagogy,Symbolism
RASHI-IS-SIMPLE RULES Complete set of rules on bottom
EMAIL: RJHendel@Juno.Com, rashi-is-simple@shamash.org,
WEB: http://www.RashiYomi.Com/
WEB: http://www.RashiYomi.Com/calendar.htm
#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*# (C) Dr Hendel, 2000 *#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*
VERSE: Dt19-09a
RULE: The Hebrew root >AYIN-VUV-DALET< means AGAIN.
NOTE: To fully appreciate Rashi we must first review
the RADACKS explanation of >AYIN-VUV-DALET<. According to Radack
the root >AYIN-VUV-DALET< has 5 meanings. They are listed below
By contrast Rashi takes these 5 meanings and unifies them--the
word always means AGAIN.
{LIST}
The 5 meanings of the Hebrew root AYIN-VUV-DALET as
brought down by the RADACK in his book ROOTS.(By
contrast Rashi below seems to suggest that there is
only one meanings, REPETITION, DOING SOMETHING AGAIN.
=====================================================
MEANING TEXT OF VERSE WITH AYIN-VUV-DLT VERSE
======= =============================== ==============
WHILE WHILE they were speaking to him Ester6-14
FOREVER There will praise you FOREVER Ps84-05
STILL The day is STILL big Gn29-07
AGAIN & God said to him AGAIN... Ex04-06
YOUTH You rode me from YOUTH Nu22-30
EXAMPLES: We now present 4 LISTS showing Rashis
explanation of the root >AYIN-VUV-DALET<. In each LIST
we show how Radack would have explained it and how Rashi
interprets it as meaning >AGAIN<.
{LIST}
----------------------------------------------------------------
In the following verses AYIN-VUV-YUD means AGAIN.
EXAMPLE:God 1st appeared to Jacob when he went to Laban(Gn28-13
When Jacob returned >God AGAIN appeared to Jacob<(Gn35-09a)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
VERSE TEXT WITH WORD >AGAIN< THE 1st TIME
======= =============================== ==============
Gn35-09a God appeared AGAIN to Jacob*1 Gn28-13
Dt19-09a add AGAIN 3 other cities*2 Dt04-41
Lv27-20c He will not redeem it AGAIN*3 Lv27-20c
Nu18-05a & there wont be a holocast AGAIN Nu17:11*4
Gn04-25b Adam knew his wife AGAIN*5 Gn04-01*5
Gn38-26a He didnt know her AGAIN*6 Gn38-15,Gn38-24*4
NOTES
=====
*1 EXAMPLE:
God 1st appeared to Jacob when he went to Laban(Gn28-13
When Jacob returned >God AGAIN appeared to Jacob<(Gn35-09a)
*2 The first 3 refuge cities were separated by Moses. The next
3 cities were separated by Joshua. In the time of the
Messiah >you will ADD AGAIN 3 cities<
*3 We will explain this verse in a separate posting in a future
issue. For now we just state the interpretation: >If a person
DOES NOT REDEEM his sanctified field (but instead gives it
to the temple) and if the temple sells it, then the original
owner does not get a chance to REDEEM IT (FOR HIMSELF)AGAIN<
*4 Thus as a punishment Korachs sin caused the holocast in
Nu17:11. Now God asks for symbols so that there should
not be another KORACH HOLOCAST
*5 Last issue we argued that the word AGAIN meant that Adam
had increased desire for this wife. Harry Rashbaum from
my Shomrey Emunah Rashi class suggested the following
simpler explanation:
5a >Adam knew his wife AGAIN<-after a long period of separation!
This is consistent with the Midrashim (brought by Rashi)
that Adam separated from his wife (which explains the 130
year gap between his wives births)
5b By contrast it is not the word AGAIN but rather
it is the comparison of Gn04-25b and Gn04-01 that teaches
us that Adam had greater desire. (I neglected to give credit
last time to the MHARZU on BRESHIT RABBAH who suggested this
approach of comparison of verses).
{LIST5}
Comparison and alignment of Gn04-01 and Gn04-25
================================================
VERSE *a *b
======= ========= ============== =====
Gn04-01 Adam knew his wife Chava
Gn04-25 Adam knew his wife again
NOTES
=====
*a Notice how one verse mentions his wife by name, Chava,while
the other verse just says his wife. There are a variety of
views of marriage in the Talmud (brought down in Shir Hashirim
Rabbah)--is the love more intense at the beginning or end of
marriage? Rashi simply points out that one verse refers to
>CHAVA his wife< while the other verse refers to >his wife<.
Thus one situation is more intimate (And you can read which
ever view of marriage you prefer into the verses).
*6 The weirdest explanations of this Rashi have occured. The
simple meaning is >HE DID NOT KNOW HER AGAIN<. Recall that the
Biblical word >KNOW< can EQUALLY MEAN >SEXUALLY KNOW< or
>PUNITIVELY KNOW<(Like the English phrase>TEACH HIM A LESSON<)
Rashi simply points out that Judah had done both to her.
In Gn38-15 he had relations with her(Hence the interpretation
>He did not know her sexually AGAIN<) In Gn38-24 he tried to
burn her(not necessarily kill her;but punish her or,as we say
in English,>teach her a lesson<.(Hence the interpretation
>He did not know her punitively AGAIN<)
{LIST}
----------------------------------------------------------------
In the following verses
>AYIN-VUV-YUD< denotes >REPETITION< vs >MORE< or >ANYMORE<.
EXAMPLE: Gn08-10 and Gn08-12 says that >Noach waited AGAIN
7 days before sending out the Dove to see if water had
disappeared< Rashi says the emphasis is on REPETITION:
>Just as Noach waited 7 days for the 2nd and 3rd sending so
too did he wait 7 days at the 1st sending<
-----------------------------------------------------------------
VERSE TEXT OF VERSE WITH AGAIN WHAT WAS REPEATED
======== =============================== =================
Gn08-08a Waited 7 days AGAIN*1 waiting 7 days
Gn07-04b Ill AGAIN give 7 days to repent 2 chances to repent*2
Gn29-30a Jacob will work 7 years AGAIN*3 Double crossed again
Dt31-02a I can't go out AGAIN (To war)*4 Moses won several wars
NOTES
=====
*1 Noach waited 7 days before the 2nd and 3rd sending of the
Dove (Gn08-10, Gn08-12). We infer he waited 7 days for
the first sending of the dove (>He waited AGAIN<)
*2 Thus Gn06-03 says that man was given 120 years to repent
before the flood. Gn07-04 says that man was AGAIN given time
to repent (another 7 days) (These interpretations are
according to Rashi)
*3 Jacob was double crossed on his pay for his 1st seven years
of work for Laban (Gn29-25). We infer that Jacob was double
crossed in his second set of 7 years of work This is
explicitly stated in Gn31-07
*4 Moses had successfully (with Gods help) won several wars
(Cf Dt02 and Dt03). Dt31 clearly states that Joshua will now
lead the people. We infer that Moses could not lead
the people in war >AGAIN< since Joshua will(cf Dt31-03:04)
{LIST}
----------------------------------------------------------------
In the following verses
>AYIN-VUV-YUD< denotes >REPETITION< vs >STILL<
EXAMPLE: Nu19-13c doesn't just mean >he is STILL impure< but
rather means >he is impure AGAIN<. The emphasis on >AGAIN<
implies that the removal of impurity is an >All or nothing<
deal. Hence, if he dipped in water but not on the proper
days then it is not the case that he is >partially impure<
but rather he is >fully< impure >AGAIN<
-----------------------------------------------------------------
VERSE TEXT OF VERSE WITH AGAIN WHY THE EMPHASIS
======== ================================ ======================
Nu19-13c the toomah is in him AGAIN*1 Fully impure
Gn45-28a I have alot: Joe lives AGAIN*2 He is still a prophet
Gn19-12a You AGAIN have someone to offer? The rape will repeat*3
Gn35-10a You wont be accused AGAIN*4 You were accused once
NOTES
=====
*1 The verse does not say >He is STILL impure< but rather
>He is impure AGAIN<. The emphasis is that EVEN if he
ritually immersed he is still FULLY impure until he
can immerse on both the 3rd and 7th day. (Without the
REPETITION I might have thought that a person could
achieve a state of partial impurity)
*2 The verse does not just say >Joe is STILL alive< but
rather >Joe lives AGAIN<. The emphasis on repetition
refers to the fact that Joseph is still a prophet and
still interpreting dreams
*3 Recall that Abraham had tried to defend the city of Sedom
from destruction. Similarly Lot probably wanted to save it
from destruction and hence showed the angels hospitality.
But after Lot could only appease the city from raping his
guests by offering his daughters it was clear that the
city could not be defended: (>Do you have someone else
to AGAIN appease another rape<)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: Ruth Shain from my Shomrey Emunah Rashi
class (correctly) pointed out that my previous explanation
in the last issue was not valid since I intepreted the verse
as >WHAT ELSE (IN TERMS OF ARGUMENTS) DO YOU HAVE AGAIN<.But
as Ruth pointed out the verse says >WHO ELSE<. Thus the
correct interpretation is >WHO ELSE AGAIN (WILL YOU OFFER)<
This combines both approaches of Rashi and is therefore
a preferred explanation.
*4 Jacobs name means >DOUBLE CROSS<. Esauv explicitly stated
>He DOUBLE CROSSED me(Esauv) twiced< (Gn27-36). Now God
promises that >After what you have been thru no one will
ever call you DOUBLE CROSS again<
{LIST}
----------------------------------------------------------------
In the following verses
>AYIN-VUV-YUD< denotes >STILL<--CONTINUATION IN TIME
EXAMPLE: Gn29-07a says >The day is STILL big<. In other
words >the day is BIG(long) now< and >the day will be
BIG AGAIN< and >the day will be big AGAIN<. Thus >STILL<
denotes >AGAIN and AGAIN< in time.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
VERSE TEXT OF VERSE WITH THE WORD >STILL<
======== ====================================
Gn08-22a The season cycle will STILL exist*1
Gn29-07a the day is STILL big*2
Ex02-03a she couldn't STILL hide him*3
Lv25-51a if there are STILL more years*4
Ex17-04a STILL a little & they will stone me*5
Gn46-29c And he STILL cried*6
NOTES
=====
*1 (Rashi) Despite the flood the world will still have
6 seasons every year.
*2 (Rashi) Whether you are self employed or work for someone
else it is not yet time to rest since the day is STILL big
I suppose the point of this Rashi is how Jacob made a
conversation opener. Jacobs statement could be seen as an
attempt to >HELP< them (>You can earn alot more<). It could
also be an attempt to show theft (>You are depriving your
employers of needed work<). By being ambiguous Jacob did
not yet play his cards since he didn't know whom he was
dealing with. Ambiguity is essential in a coversation
opener.
*3 Rashi gives a reason why she couldn't hide him: If Moses
was born at 6 months then his mother could hide him for
3 months since no one expected a baby yet. But at 9 months
she could no longer hide him.
*4 Rashi simply shows the conputation for the >STRAIGHT LINE<
method. REDEMPTION of workers slaves and fields is
strictly proportional to the number of years left to the
Jubilee.
*5 >STILL a LITTLE< means >IN A LITTLE BIT< and is a
idiom with a special meaning.
*6 Rashi explicitly states that >There was ALOT of crying<
COMMENT: We bring down the interesting Sifrah/Sifray on
Nu18-05a which cites 4 verses with the phrase >NOT AGAIN<
(Gn09-11, Nu18-05a, Nu18-22, Lv17-07). The >AGAIN< in these
verses is cross referenced.
COMMENT: I have brought down the Rashi-Radack controversy
But I have not yet shown its deeper root. As we shall see
there are several controversies between Rashi and other
Rishonim on meaning.>RASHI ALWAYS EMPHASIZES A UNIFIED
APPROACH AND IT IS THIS EMPHASiS ON UNITY WHICH CAUSES
THE CONTROVERSY BETWEEN RASHI AND OTHER RISHONIM<
#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*# (C) Dr Hendel, 2000 *#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*
THE 2 DOZEN RASHI-IS-SIMPLE RASHI RULES
http://www.RashiYomi.Com/rules.htm
=======================================
http://www.RashiYomi.Com/rules9-6.htm
=======================================
I: RASHI gives MEANING
======================
A: NEW MEANINGS--(eg)"on the face of"=during the lifetime
Volume 2 Number 9, http://www.rashiyomi.Com/Nu04-04a.htm
B: SPECIAL WORDS--(eg)ACH=USUALLY;USUALLY observe shabbath!
Rashi Yomi Summaries,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Ach-6.htm
C: SYNONYMS--(eg)AMR=to speak; DBR=to cite or to quote;
Volume 2 Number 1, http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Lv20-02a.htm
D: WORD MEANINGS-Thermos(TzNTzNTh)=doubly(TZN TZN) Cold(TZN)
Volume 1 Number 9,23,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Ex31-15a.htm
E: UNIFIED MEANINGS-PAAM=Repeated action:To Ring,Hammer,Step
Volume 1 Number 3,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Gn41-08a.htm
II: RASHI teaches GRAMMAR/STYLE
===============================
F: CLASSICAL GRAMMAR--(eg)QUESTION = HEY+CHATAF PATACH
Volume 3 Number 22,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Gn04-09z.htm
G: USAGE(NEW GRAMMAR)--(eg)INFINITIVE="be involved in";
Volume 5 Number 24,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Ex13-03a.htm
H: ROOT+PREPOSITION--(eg)ChZK B="to hold";ChZK M="overpower"
Volume 1 Number 7,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Ex04-04a.htm
I: THE SENTENCE--2 verses can make 1 sentence-eg Dt02-16:17
Volume 3 Number 7,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Dt19-06a.htm
J: STYLE--REPETITION denotes Endearment;eg 'Jacob Jacob'
Volume 1 Number 12,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Gn46-02a.htm
K: DOUBLE NOUNS--(eg)"GIVE GIVE";if not CHARITY then LOAN
Double Noun page, http://www.RashiYomi.Com/DN.htm
L: PRONOUNS-(eg)IMCHAH=with you; ITCHAH=Accompanying you;
Volume 3 Number 13,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Ex22-24c.htm
III: OVERALL TEXTUAL STRUCTURE
==============================
M: OTHER VERSES--Aaron SAW(Ex32-05)...the brawl(Ex32-18)
OTHER VERSE page, http://www.RashiYomi.Com/ov.htm
N: EXTRA SENTENCES-eg[GIVE HIM][WHAT HE NEEDS](Not if rich)
Volume 2 Number 20,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Dt15-08c.htm
O: DOUBLE PARSHAS-'he WILL pray'-'he WON'T pray';So Optional
Volume 3 Number 12,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Dt24-14a.htm
P: CLIMAX-(eg Dt19-11)(a)Hate, (b)spy, (c)confront,(d)Murder
Climax Page, http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Climax.htm
Q: OVERALL STRUCTURE-growing nails=despisement(from context)
Volume 3 Number 8,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Dt21-11a.htm
R: SPREADSHEETS-What is the marriage loophole in inheritance
Volume 2 Number 23,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Nu36-03a.htm
IV: BEYOND THE TEXT
===================
S: MORAL LESSONS/REASONS-God explains BEFORE punishing;
Volume 2 Number 12,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Nu12-09a.htm
T: RabbiIshmael-(eg)"When an OX gores";(Or ANY animal gores)
Volume 4 Number 21,http://www.RashiYomi.Com/Dt25-04a.htm
End of Rashi-Is-Simple Digest
#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*# (C) Dr Hendel, 2000 *#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*