The goal of this Weekly Rashi Digest
is to use the weekly Torah portion to expose
students at all levels to the ten major methods of commentary used by Rashi.
It is hoped that continual weekly exposure to these
ten major methods will enable students of all levels to acquire
a familiarity and facility with the major exegetical methods.
FULL HOUSE THIS WEEK ALL RASHI RULES ILLUSTRATED
Using the verses below, which
discuss
the deal Moses made with Reuvenites and Gadites
Rashi clarifies
that the deal consisted of the Reuvenites and Gadites fighting with the
Jews for the conquest of Israel in return for which they received the
transJordan.
Target Verse
|
Text
|
Cross Reference
|
Text
|
Rashi Comment
|
Dt03-18a:20
|
And I commanded you at that time, saying: 'The HaShem your G-d hath given you this land to possess it; ye shall pass over armed before your brethren the children of Israel, all the men of valour.
But your wives, and your little ones, and your cattle ....shall abide in your cities which I have given you;
until .... they also possess the land ....
|
Nu32-25:27
|
And the children of Gad and the children of Reuben spoke unto Moses, saying: 'Thy servants
will do as my lord commandeth.
Our little ones, our wives, our flocks, and all our cattle, shall be there in the cities of Gilead;
but thy servants will pass over,....armed for war, ....
|
Rashi illumines the underlined words
The deal/command with the Reuvenites-Gadites was that
(a) they fight with the Jews for the conquest of Israel
in return for which (b) they inherit the TransJordan.
|
The focus of a meaning Rashi does not have to be
on defining an unknown term. Sometimes Rashi will present
nuances of synonyms thereby crystalizing the true
meaning and essence of a word.
Rashi believes that the Biblical root
Yud-Daleth-Hey means familiar. This
root is incorrectly translated as to know.
The verses and examples below illustrate the higher precision
of using the translation familiar.
-
Gn04-01
And Adam was familiar with his wife; and she conceived and bore Cain, and said: 'I have gotten a man with the help of HaShem.'
-
Dt34-10
And there hath not arisen a prophet since in Israel like unto Moses,
whom HaShem was familiar with as in a face to face relationship;
-
Ex01-08
Now there arose a new Monarchy over Egypt, who was not familiar with Joseph
-
Dt01-13
Get you, wise men, and understanding,
familiar to your tribes
and I will make them heads over you.'
Rashi knew the following conjugation rule: Each Biblical root has a grammatical
form indicating the infinitive. The same infinitive grammatical form can, besides
meaning the infinitive, also mean an ongoing intensive effort. Some sample verses
and Rashis are cited below. Note how we incorporate the Rashi comment into the translation.
-
Ex20-08
Be involved in Remembering the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
[Rashi: Remember the Sabbath each day. For example if you
see a good dish on the weekday, then purchase it for the Sabbath.]
-
Ex13-03
And Moses said unto the people:
'Be involved in remembering this day,
in which ye came out from Egypt, out of the house of bondage; for by strength of hand HaShem brought you out from this place; there shall no leavened bread be eaten.
[Rashi: You should remember the exodus every day.]
-
Dt01-16a
And I charged your judges at that time, saying:
'Be involved in hearing cases between your brethren, and judge righteously between a man and his brother, and the stranger that is with him.
[Rashi: Don't e.g. judge a case immediately but rather, in serious cases, wait at least one night
before passing verdict (even if you have seen similar cases many times).]
The table below presents an aligned extract of verses in Dt03-18b:20 and
Nu32-25:27.
Both verses
discuss
the deal for the Reubenites-Gadites to fight with the Jews in the conquest of Israel.
The alignment justifies the Rashi assertion that
- The requirement was for the Reubenites-Gadites to fight with the Jews in
their conquest of Israel
- However in actuality the Reubenites-Gadites led the Jews in battle.
Verse
|
Text of Verse
|
Rashi comment
|
Dt03-18b:20
|
And I commanded you at that time, saying: 'The HaShem your G-d hath given you this land to possess it;
ye shall pass over armed before your brethren the children of Israel, all the men of valour.
But your wives, and your little ones, and your cattle--I know that ye have much cattle--shall abide in your cities which I have given you;
until HaShem give rest unto your brethren, as unto you, and they also possess the land which HaShem your G-d giveth them beyond the Jordan; then shall ye return every man unto his possession, which I have given you.
|
|
Nu32-25:27
|
And the children of Gad and the children of Reuben spoke unto Moses, saying: 'Thy servants will do as my lord commandeth.
Our little ones, our wives, our flocks, and all our cattle, shall be there in the cities of Gilead;
but thy servants will pass over, every man that is armed for war, before HaShem to battle, as my lord saith.'
|
- The deal was for them to pass over before Hashem.
- However they volunteered to pass over before their brothers (To lead).
|
The table below presents presents
two contradictory verses.
Both verses speak about
the report of the spies.
The underlined words highlight the contradiction.
One verse says
that the spies reported that the land of Israel was good
while the other verse says
that the spies reported that the land of Israel was bad.
Which is it?
Did the spies say the land was good or bad?
Summary
|
Verse / Source
|
Text of verse / Source
|
Spie's report: The land of Israel is bad.
|
Nu13-32
|
And they spread an bad report of the land which they had spied out unto the children of Israel, saying:
'The land, through which we have passed to spy it out, is a land that eateth up the inhabitants thereof; and all the people that we saw in it are men of great stature.
|
Spie's report: The land of Israel is good.
|
Dt01-25b
|
And they took of the fruit of the land in their hands, and brought it down unto us,
and brought us back word, and said: 'Good is the land which HaShem our G-d giveth unto us.'
|
Resolution:
|
2 Aspects
|
- The majority of spies reported the land was bad.
- The minority of spies (Kaleb and Joshua) reported the land was good.
|
Rashi resolves this contradiction using the 2 aspects
method.
- The majority of spies reported the land was bad.
- The minority of spies (Kaleb and Joshua) reported the land was good.
By using the table structure
with underlines we are able to participate and empathize with Rashi in
construction of the Rashi comment.
Stating an abstract principle is not the only way to teach a principle.
Some people learn better from examples then from general abstractions.
The literary method used is called synechdoche, indicating a
general class by a nifty good example. In Talmudic lingo we call this
generaliztaion. Every day, during our prayer, we recite the 13 Rabbi Ishmael style rules
including the generalization rule.
Verse Dt01-17b discussing judicial equality states
Ye shall not respect persons in judgment;
ye shall hear the small
[person] and the great
[person] alike;
ye shall not be afraid of the face of any man; for the judgment is G-d's; and the cause that is too hard for you ye shall bring unto me, and I will hear it.'
Rashi generalizes this. After all,
great people typically have cases involving great amounts,
while small people typically have cases involving small amounts.
Hence the Rashi comment:
Treat cases involving large sums and cases
involving small sums alike (With equal attention and detail).
We have explained in our article
Biblical Formatting located on the world wide web at
http://www.Rashiyomi.com/biblicalformatting.pdf,
that the Biblical Author indicated bullets
by using repeating keywords.
That is, if a modern
author wanted to get a point across using bullets,
a list of similar but contrastive items,
then the Biblical
Author would use repeating keywords.
This principle can be illustrated with verse Dt01-22
which discusses Moses instuction to the spiees:
And you came near me every one of you, and said, We will send men before us, and they shall spy the land, and bring us word
- Of which road to go up on, and
- Of which cities to come to [for conquest.]
Here the repeating Biblical keyword,
Aleph Tauv which we have translated of
indicates a bullet effect. The bullets emphasize
a group of two items to be searched out by the spies
for the conquest. Rashi's task is to emphasize the distinctness
of each of these items:
- Which road to go up: To avoid ambushes in crooked roads
- Which cities to come to: Which cities are easiest
to conquer first.
In summary Rashi sees the repeating keyword as indicating
bullets. The bullets in turn emphasize
a group of concerns for spies: the
identification of the good roads and easy cities to conquer.
We ask the following database query:
Does crying facilitate prayer and petition being ansewred?
The reader is encouraged to perform the query using a standard Biblical Konnkordance or search engine.
This database query yields the list below.
The list justifies the following shocking Rashi inference:
God typically answers prayer accompanied by crying except in the case of slander.
A slanderer who sincerely crys in his/her prayer is not answered.
Verse
| Text of Verse
| Who Cried
| To Whom
| Why Cry
| Response
|
Gn21-16:17
|
And she went, and sat ...down..., and lifted up her voice, and wept.
And G-d heard the voice of the lad; .... fear not; for G-d hath heard the voice ...
| Hagar
| God
| Child dying
| God heard
|
Gn27-38:39
|
And Esau said unto his father: 'Hast thou but one blessing, my father? ....' And Esau lifted up his voice, and wept.
And Isaac his father answered and said unto him: Behold, of the fat places of the earth ...,
| Esauv
| Father
| Wanted a blessing
| He obtained a blessing
|
Jr31-14:15
|
Thus saith HaShem: A voice is heard in Ramah, lamentation, and bitter weeping,
Rachel weeping for her children;....
Thus saith HaShem: .... thy work shall be rewarded,
| Rachel
| God
| Her Children suffering
| God rewards her
|
Dt01-45a
|
And ye returned and wept before HaShem; but HaShem hearkened not to your voice, ....
| Jews
| Wept
| God refused them entry into Israel
| God refused to listen [Rashi: Slander turns God's mercy into cruelty]
|
Verse Dt03-16
discussing
the portion that Moses gave the Reuvenites and Gadites
states
And unto the Reubenites and unto the Gadites I gave from
Gilead even unto the Arnon river,
the middle of the river and a border; even unto the river Jabbok, which is the border of the children of Ammon;
Rashi explains the diagrammatic meaning of the underlined phrase
middle of the river and a border:
-
The underlined phrase middle of the river refers to the water (in the midst of
the river) - that is, they acquired the river proper.
- The underlined phrase and a border means they also acquired a
little bit of the land border of the opposing river side.
In other words they inherited a piece of land along with both the river
and a little land on the side. (If they only had a natural border of a river
boats could not dock on the river side since the property would belong to
someone else.)
Advanced Rashi: The adventuresome student is invited
to draw a diagram illustrating the above. The diagram should show
how they acquire (a) the land (b) the river itself and (c) a little bit of
river side.
Military activity is often vigorously described
using animal metaphors. Here we use the symbolism
principle that items can symbolize their function.
Examples are plentiful
- Nu24-09 states
He couched, he lay down as a
lion, and as a great
lion. Who shall stir him up? Blessed is he who blesses you, and cursed is he who curses you.
- Jr05-06 states
Therefore a lion from the forest shall slay them,
and a wolf of the deserts shall destroy them,
a leopard shall watch over their cities;
every one who goes out there shall be torn in pieces; because their transgressions are many, and their apostasies are great.
- Jr46-12 states
Her sound is like that of a serpent on the move;
for they shall march with force, and come against
her with axes, like wood cutters.
- Dt01-44a states
And the Amorites,
who lived in that mountain,
came out against you,
and chased you,
as bees do,
and destroyed you in Seir, even unto Hormah.
The interpreter's task is to identify the unique military
characteristics of each animal. Rashi commenting on the last
verse Dt01-44a states
The military characteristic of the bee is the swiftness
of conquest without exertion of power. That is a bee kills
thru an instantaneous sting with venom, not by the type of
power and interactive fight shown by a lion.
This week's parshah contains examples of all Rashi
methods.
This concludes this weeks edition.
Visit the RashiYomi website at
http://www.Rashiyomi.com
for further details and examples.
|