The 10 RashiYomi Rules
Their presence in Rashis on Parshat DeVaRiM
Volume 11, Number 5
Rashi is Simple - Volume 34 Number 5

Used in the weekly Rashi-is-Simple and the Daily Rashi.
Visit the RashiYomi website: http://www.Rashiyomi.com/
(c) RashiYomi Incorporated, Dr. Hendel, President,
August 7th, 2008

The goal of this Weekly Rashi Digest is to use the weekly Torah portion to expose students at all levels to the ten major methods of commentary used by Rashi. It is hoped that continual weekly exposure to these ten major methods will enable students of all levels to acquire a familiarity and facility with the major exegetical methods.

FULL HOUSE THIS WEEK ALL RASHI RULES ILLUSTRATED

    1. RASHI METHOD: REFERENCES
    BRIEF EXPLANATION: Commentary on a verse is provided thru a cross-reference to another verse. The cross references can either provide
    • (1a) further details,
    • (1b) confirm citations, or
    • (1c) clarify word meaning.
    This examples applies to Rashis Dt02-16c
    URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm;
    Brief Summary: The MEN OF WAR mentioned in Dt02-16 refers to 20+ year olds Nu14-29 on whom death was decreed. 20+ is military age (e.g. Nu01-20)

Verse Dt02-16, discussing the death of the men of war states So it came to pass, when all the men of war had completed dying from the people, Rashi clarifies the underlined words men of war by referencing verse(s) Nu14-29,Nu01-20 discussing the death decree on those who accepted the slander of the spies which states Your carcasses shall fall in this wilderness; and all who were counted of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, who have murmured against me And the sons of Reuben, Israel?s eldest son, by their generations, according to their families, by the house of their fathers, according to the number of the names, by their polls, every male from twenty years old and upward, all who were able to go forth to war; Hence the Rashi comment: The men of war mentioned in Dt02-16 refers to the 20+ year olds who accepted the slander of spies on whom was decreed death. These 20+ year olds are called men of war since 20 is the age of military conscription (Nu01-20).

Text of Target verse Dt02-16 Text of Reference Verse Nu14-29,Nu01-20
So it came to pass, when all the men of war had completed dying from among the nation, Your carcasses shall fall in this wilderness; and all who were counted of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, who have murmured against me ... ...And the sons of Reuben, Israel?s eldest son, by their generations, according to their families, by the house of their fathers, according to the number of the names, by their polls, every male from twenty years old and upward, all who were able to go forth to war;
Rashi comments: The men of war who died mentioned in Dt02-16 refers to the 20+ year olds who accepted the slander of spies on whom was decreed death. These 20+ year olds are called men of war since 20 is the age of military conscription (Nu01-20).

Advanced Rashi: Note the unusual feature that we have a nested reference, in the above example. Men of war who died references the 20+ year olds on whom was decreed death and 20+ year olds references the census where we are told that 20 is the age of military conscription.

We will revisit this example below in rule #2, meaning, and rule #3, grammar.

      2. RASHI METHOD: WORD MEANING
      BRIEF EXPLANATION: The meaning of words can be explained either by
      • (2a) translating an idiom, a group of words whose collective meaning transcends the meaning of its individual component words,
      • (2b) explaining the nuances and commonality of synonyms-homographs,
      • (2c) describing the usages of connective words like also,because,if-then, when,
      • (2d) indicating how grammatical conjugation can change word meaning
      • (2e) changing word meaning using the figures of speech common to all languages such as irony and oxymorons.
      This examples applies to Rashis Dt02-16c
      URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
      Brief Summary: The phase MEN OF WAR is an idiom meaning MEN OF MILITARY CONSCRIPTION AGE, DRAFTABLE MEN.

An idiom is a collection of words which means more than the sum of the meanings of each of the phrases' individual words. Verse Dt02-16c discussing the death of the men of war states So it came to pass, when all the men of war had completed dying from the nation, Rashi explains: The phrase men of war is an idiom meaning men of military conscription age, draftable men We can compactly combine the Rashi comment with the Biblical text by translating as follows: So it came to pass, when all the draftable men had completed dying from the nation,

In my article Peshat and Derash found on the world wide web at http://www.Rashiyomi.com/rashi.pdf I advocate enriching the Rashi explanation using a technique of parallel nifty translations in modern English. Today's examples show this.

Advanced Rashi: In rule #1, reference we found that Dt02-16 referenced Nu14-29 which stated that all 20+ year olds who accepted the slander of the spies would die. Verse Nu01-20 then explains that 20 is the age of military conscription. These references motivate translating the idiom, men of war as draftable men.

      3. RASHI METHOD: GRAMMAR
      BRIEF EXPLANATION: Rashi explains verses using grammar principles, that is, rules which relate reproducable word form to word meaning. Grammatical rules neatly fall into 3 categories
      • (a) the rules governing conjugation of individual words,Biblical roots,
      • (b) the rules governing collections of words,clauses, sentences
      • (c) miscellaneous grammatical, or form-meaning, rules.
      This examples applies to Rashis Dt02-16a
      URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
      Brief Summary: WHEN ALL DRAFTABLE MEN DIED THEN GOD SPOKE TO ME. Rashi: This teaches God only spoke to Moses for the sake of the community.

The multi-verse rule simply states that some Biblical sentences span multiple verses. Knowledge of the multi-verse rule enables one to see distinct Biblical sentences as contributing meaning to each other. Today's example illustrates this.

Verses Dt02-16:17 state So it came to pass, when all draftable men had completed dying from the nation, [then] the Lord spoke to me, saying. We have indicated Rashi's comment, that the two verses form one sentence, by interpolating the typeset word then, indicating causal or temporal connection between the two verses. Rashi further elaborates: Why does the verse emphasize the causal relation that God spoke to Moses after the draftable men [who accepted the slander of the spies] completed dying? This causal relation indicates that God only prophetically spoke to Moses for the sake of the community. As long as people were dying and not going to enter Israel there was no need for God to speak to Moses.

    Advanced Rashi: We have studied Dt02-16:17 using three Rashi methods:
  • The meaning method taught us that the phrase men of war is an idiom meaning draftable men.
  • The reference method taught us that the draftable men who completed dying refers to the 20+ year olds who accepted the slander of the spies on whom death was decreed. The reference method further teaches us that 20 is age of military drafting. These references in turn enable us to decipher the idiom.
  • The grammar method taught us that the two verses - one speaking about the cessation of dying of draftable men and the other speaking about God delivering prophecy to Moses - were causally connected because God only spoke to Moses for the sake of the community.

    4. RASHI METHOD: ALIGNMENT
    BRIEF EXPLANATION: Aligning two almost identically worded verselets can suggest
    • (4a) 2 cases of the same incident or law
    • (4b) emphasis on the nuances of a case
    • (4c) use of broad vs literal usage of words
    This examples applies to Rashis Dt02-32a
    URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
    Brief Summary: Both Moab and Bashan were afraid of the Jews Moab sought an alliance; Bashan did not, showing the military independence of Bashan.

The table below presents an aligned extract of verses or verselets in Nu21-23, Nu22-03:04 Both verses/verselets discuss the military fear the nations had of the Jews. The alignment justifies the Rashi comment that: Both Moab and Bashan were afraid of Jewish usage of their resources. Moab made an alliance with Midian against the Jews while Bashan went to war immediately. This shows that Bashan was militarily independent.

Verse Text of Verse Rashi comment
Nu21-23
  • And Sihon would not allow Israel to pass through his border;
  • but Sihon gathered all his people together, and went out against Israel into the wilderness;
  • and he came to Jahaz, and fought against Israel
Both Moab and Bashan were afraid of Jewish usage of their resources. Moab made an alliance with Midian against the Jews while Bashan went to war immediately. This shows that Bashan was militarily independent.
Nu22-03:04
  • And Moab was very afraid of the people, because they were many; and
  • Moab was distressed because of the people of Israel.
  • And Moab said to the elders of Midian, Now shall this company lick up all who are around us, as the ox licks up the grass of the field. And Balak the son of Zippor was king of the Moabites at that time.

      5. RASHI METHOD: CONTRADICTION
      BRIEF EXPLANATION:Rashi resolves contradictory verses using 3 methods.
      • (5a) Resolution using two aspects of the same event
      • (5b) Resolution using two stages of the same process
      • (5c) Resolution using broad-literal interpretation.
      This examples applies to Rashis Dt01-27c
      URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
      Brief Summary: The Jews complained that GOD HATES US. But God loved the Jews? The Jews projected their own hatred of God onto God.

The table below presents two contradictory verses. Both verses talk about the emotional attitude of God to the Jews. The underlined words highlight the contradiction. One verse says God hates us [the Jews] while the other verse says ...because of God's love of you [the Jews] Which is it? Does God love or hate the Jews. Rashi simply resolves this using the broad-literal method: The statement that God loves the Jews is true. The statement of the Jews because of God's hatred of us can be interpreted using the psychological phenomena of projection - that is, the Jews projected their own hatred of God onto God's attitude towards them.

Summary Verse / Source Text of verse / Source
God hates the Jews Dt01-27 And you murmured in your tents, and said, Because the Lord hated us [the Jews], He has brought us out of the land of Egypt, to deliver us into the hand of the Amorites, to destroy us.
God loves the Jews Dt07-08 But because of the Love of the Lord towards you [the Jews], and because he would keep the oath which he had sworn to your fathers, has the Lord brought you out with a mighty hand, and redeemed you out of the house of slaves, from the hand of Pharaoh king of Egypt.
Resolution: Broad-literal The statement that God loves the Jews is true. The statement of the Jews because of God's hatred of us can be interpreted using the psychological phenomena of projection - that is, the Jews projected their own hatred of God onto God's attitude towards them.

    6. RASHI METHOD: STYLE
    Rashi examines how rules of style influences inferences between general and detail statements in paragraphs.
    • Example: Every solo example stated by the Bible must be broadly generalized;
    • Theme-Detail: A general principle followed by an example is interpreted restrictively---the general theme statement only applies in the case of the example;
    • Theme-Detail-Theme: A Theme-Detail-Theme unit is interpreted as a paragraph. Consequently the details of the paragraph are generalized so that they are seen as illustrative of the theme.
    This examples applies to Rashis Dt02-04a URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/dt02-04a.htm
    Brief Summary: The Jews complained that GOD HATES US. But God loved the Jews? The Jews projected their own hatred of God onto God.

The Rabbi Ishmael Style rules indicate how verses should be treated, whether literally and restrictively or generally and broadly as paradigms. The General-Detail style indicates a restrictive literal interpretation--the general clause is restricted to the specific requirements of the detail clause.

    Dt02-04a:05 is written in a general-detail style. And command the people, saying, You are to pass through the border of your brothers the sons of Esau, who live in Seir; and they shall be afraid of you;
  • General: take heed and watch yourselves [by]
  • Detail: Contend not with them; for I will not give you of their land, no, not so much as a foot breadth; because I have given Mount Seir to Esau for a possession.

Rashi comments by adding the interpolated word [by] linking the General-detail clauses and giving them specificity. Take heed and watch yourselves [by] not contending with them.

Here is another way of understanding this Rashi. The statement take heed and watch yourself is very broad and general. It could refer to not insulting them. It could even refer to not entering commerce with them. However the general-detail combination, take heed [by] not contending with them...I will not give you of their land makes it clear that the only prohibition is military contention---the Jews were prohibited from military conflict with the Moabites. However other forms of contention are not prohibited.

In fact Rashi elsewhere notes that the phrase ...and they shall be afraid of you... indicates that it was permissable for the Jews to go thru Seir armed, even though they could not enter into war and even though they would cause anxiety to the Moabites when they saw an armed nation going through their land.

Last week we augmented the weekly Rashi with presentations of controversies among the early authorities. We continue the trend this week by presenting an attachment discussing a controversy between Rashi and Sforno on the above Rashi. The attachment may be found at http://www.Rashiyomi.com/rule1105.rtf

    7. RASHI METHOD: FORMATTING
    BRIEF EXPLANATION:Inferences from Biblical formatting:
    • Use of repetition to indicate formatting effects: bold,italics,...;
    • use of repeated keywords to indicate a bullet effect;
    • rules governing use and interpretation of climactic sequence;
    • rules governing paragraph development and discourse
    This examples applies to Rashis Dt01-22c Dt01-22d
    URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/dt01-22c.htm
    Brief Summary: Spies were to find a) easiest CITIES to conquer b) crooked ROADS with potential ambushes

We have explained in our article Biblical Formatting located on the world wide web at http://www.Rashiyomi.com/biblicalformatting.pdf, that the Biblical Author indicated bullets by using repeating keywords.

That is, if a modern author wanted to get a point across using bullets, a list of similar but contrastive items, then the Biblical Author would use repeating keywords.

    This principle can be illustrated with verse Dt01-22 which discusses Moses' instuction to the spiees: And you came near me every one of you, and said, We will send men before us, and they shall spy the land, and bring us word
  • Of which road to go up on, [to avoid ambushes on crooked roads] and
  • Of which cities to come to [for conquest.]

Advanced Rashi: In summary Rashi sees the repeating keyword, of, as indicating bullets. The bullets in turn emphasize a group of distinct concerns for spies: the identification of the good roads and the identification of the easy cities to conquer. As usual we have embedded the Rashi comments in the above translation.

      8. RASHI METHOD: DATABASES
      BRIEF EXPLANATION:Rashi makes inferences from Database queries. The precise definition of database query has been identified in modern times with the 8 operations of Sequential Query Language (SQL).

      This example applies to Rashis Dt02-31a
      URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
      Brief Summary: The word SEE when used repetitively or without a sight connotes PROPHETIC VISION.

Today we ask the database query: When should the word see be translated as prophetically see. The query uncovers 5 examples. An examination of these examples justifies the Rashi assertion that When the word see is used repetitively or without actual sight it should be interpreted as prophetically see. The table below presents results of the query along with illustrations of Rashi's comment.

Verse Text of Verse Repetition Translation of see
Gn18-01:02 And the Lord appeared to Abraham... And he ... saw and, lo, three men stood by him; and he saw ..., he ran to meet ... appear, saw, saw And the Lord appeared to Abraham... And he ... saw and, lo, three men stood by him; and he prophetically understood ..., he ran to meet ...
Gn42-01:02 Now Jacob saw that there was grain in Egypt, Jacob said .... ... Behold, I have heard that there is grain in Egypt; go down saw, heard Now Jacob prophetically saw that there was grain in Egypt, Jacob said .... ... Behold, I have heard that there is grain in Egypt; go down
Ex02-12 And he turned this way and that way, and he saw that there was no man, he slew the Egyptian, and hid him... turned, saw And he turned this way and that way, and he prophetically saw that there was no [righteous] man [descending from him], he slew the Egyptian, and hid him...
Dt02-31:32 And the Lord said to me, see, I have begun to give Sihon and his land before you; begin the conquest to inherit his land. Then Sihon came out .... see, then he came out And the Lord said to me, prohpetically see, I have begun to give Sihon and his land before you; begin the conquest to inherit his land. Then Sihon came out ....
Gn48-01:08 And it came to pass after these things, that one told Joseph, Behold, your father is sick; and he took with him his two sons, Manasseh and Ephraim ...And Israel saw Joseph?s sons, and said, Who are these? took his two sons, saw, who are these And it came to pass after these things, that one told Joseph, Behold, your father is sick; and he took with him his two sons, Manasseh and Ephraim ...And Israel prophetically saw Joseph?s sons [descendants], and said, Who are these?

In all these verses the word see is either unnecessarily repeated, or, there is nothing yet to see, or, in the last example, Jacob not knowing what he saw does not make sense in context. In all these examples Rashi interprets see as prophetically see.

The Rambam also applies this principle to derive that certain Biblical scenes are really prophetic visions. Thus the Rambam interprets the famous dialog of God and Abraham on the destruction of Sedom and Gemorroh, including the entire preceding paragraph, as a vision. Similarly the Rambam interprets the famous passage of Bilam's dialogue with his donkey as happening in a prophetic vision. This has important philosophic implications: For example, if Abraham's dialogue with God took place in a dream then we cannot infer that one should question God's orders with our logic. Rather God granted Abraham the right to understand through prophetic vision God's reasons for destroying entire cities. Abraham never actually questioned God just as Abraham didn't question God when he was asked to offer his son. The prophetic vision was a means of enlightening Abraham on God's way of running the world, not a justification to question prophetic orders. More could be said but I simply wanted to show how this principle can be applied exegetically.

    9. RASHI METHOD: SPREADSHEETS
    BRIEF EXPLANATION: The common denominator of the 3 submethods of the Spreadsheet method is that inferences are made from non textual material. The 3 submethods are as follows:
    • Spreadsheet: Rashi makes inferences of a numerical nature that can be summarized in a traditional spreadsheet
    • Geometric: Rashi clarifies a Biblical text using descriptions of geometric diagrams
    • Fill-ins: Rashi supplies either real-world background material or indicates real-world inferences from a verse. The emphasis here is on the real-world, non-textual nature of the material.
    This example applies to Rashis Dt02-03a
    URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/w34n5.htm
    Brief Summary: turn/face NORTHWARDS = walk on the EAST coast, FROM the SOUTH end TO the NORTH end.

Verse Dt02-03a states You have wandered around this mountain long enough; turn/face northward Rashi interprets the underlined phrase, turn/face northward, diagramatically, Face northward means to walk along on the east cost from the south to the north. Rashi's diagramtic statement is illustrated in the diagram below.

'	---------NORTH-------------|
'                                  |
'                                  ^
'                                  |EAST
'                                  |
'                                  ^
'     --------- SOUTH --------------

      10. RASHI METHOD: SYMBOLISM
      BRIEF EXPLANATION: Rashi provides symbolic interpretations of words, verses, and chapters. Rashi can symbolically interpret either
      • (10a) entire Biblical chapters such as the gifts of the princes, Nu-07
      • (10b) individual items, verses and words
      The rules governing symbolism and symbolic interpretation are presented in detail on my website.

      This examples applies to Rashis Dt01-44
      URL Reference: (c) http://www.Rashiyomi.com/dt01-44a.htm
      Brief Summary: The LION kills through POWER; the BEE kills thru VENOM without using power.

    Military activity is often vigorously described using animal metaphors. Here we use the symbolism principle that items can symbolize their function. Examples are plentiful
  • Nu24-09 states He couched, he lay down as a lion, and as a great lion. Who shall stir him up? Blessed is he who blesses you, and cursed is he who curses you.
  • Jr05-06 states Therefore a lion from the forest shall slay them, and a wolf of the deserts shall destroy them, a leopard shall watch over their cities; every one who goes out there shall be torn in pieces; because their transgressions are many, and their apostasies are great.
  • Jr46-12 states Her sound is like that of a serpent on the move; for they shall march with force, and come against her with axes, like wood cutters.
  • Dt01-44a states And the Amorites, who lived in that mountain, came out against you, and chased you, as bees do, and destroyed you in Seir, even unto Hormah.

The interpreter's task is to identify the unique military characteristics of each animal. Rashi commenting on the last verse Dt01-44a states The military characteristic of the bee is the swiftness of conquest without exertion of power. That is a bee kills thru an instantaneous sting with venom, not by the type of power and interactive fight shown by a lion.

Conclusion

This week's parshah contains examples of all Rashi methods. Visit the RashiYomi website at http://www.Rashiyomi.com for further details and examples.